Pizza cuisine: the best places to taste it in Utica
31 restaurant menus in Utica, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Today my office ordered lunch for my last day with the agency. Everyone ordered their own different meal, and everyone left the table with a full,..."
Miranda Graf
"This place is amazing! Me and my husband order from here all the time and every single time it taste great, the owner and staff are awesome! I highly..."
Jaime Lynn
"Fantastic pizza! Staff was awesome! We had a group of 13 and they were so accommodating. We took up a good portion of the dining room and they didn't..."
Tricia DaPonte
"This place is just awesome. Every time we call or go in, he is exceptionally friendly! And the pizza is phenomenal. Philly steak subs are delicious..."
Julie Arcuri
"Ordered from here for first time yesterday was very pleased I was warned in advance of the 1 hour delivery wait which I was OK with and despite the..."
Olivia Jones
"Been going here for years for a reason, top quality at the best price. You can’t beat their hospitality either, you feel like family..."
Jason Maxfield
"Every time I come here the place is fantastic. I could eat this pie all day. Wings are huge and the service is always top notch. Very..."
John Constantine
"Hands down the best chicken wrap I’ve ever had. Everything’s so fresh . Definitely will be ordering from here..."
Krystin Dawes
"Had my first pizza from here yesterday and it was honestly amazing good sauce,crust had great flavor and great price what more could you ask..."
Damian Schreiner
"Best pizza for the best price in Utica. Friendly staff and great..."
Daniel Deluke
"OMG!!! This place reminds me of a New York City pizza joint from an alleyway through a brick wall is how they served..."
Michael J. Henderson
"Pizza was great and the wings were better! Came in with a large group and everyone was very accommodating and friendly! Definitely..."
Matt Morin
"this place is absolutely fantastic, i love everything about the pizza and environment, and the owners are the nicest people you will ever..."
Jimmy Thai
"My first visit to Jonny's, and it won't be my last; the slices are big enough to use as a life raft! Best upside down pizza since Leo's (on Jame's..."
Terry Marshall
"They probably have the best pizza in the area and the price is reasonable..."
Tony Tuấn Củ
"Best pizza in the area ....clean,cozy little pizza shop and staff are some of the..."
Brandon Tracy
"I ordered a half tray of Chicken Wing Riggies this past weekend for Super Bowl. I live in Liverpool and have never been to Jonny's so because I had..."
Sharon Carrow
"I consistently have an awesome experience every time I visit Jonny's. I love going in for slices to see what they have that day. My favorites are..."
Sarah Foster
"Great pizza joint. I come here often for lunch. They serve one of the best Philly Steak sandwiches in the area and possibly most of the north east..."
Vitaly Umanov
"The fried ravioli was good, the pizza sauce tasted a bit watered down though with a chlorine kind of taste, like maybe hard tap water was used in it...."
J Tole
"Do you want authentic thin sliced pizza? Then this is the place to go. Large slices. You'll think you're on the streets of..."
Joshua Amodio
"The place itself is very clean. The food comes in big portions and is very delicious. The signature pizza in hand tossed and places in the top 5 best..."
William Williams
"Have been here several times. Typical big family new York Pizza joint. Being from Chicago, I don't care for NY pizza but I love this place. Will..."
Jason Gallivan
"Very good pizza and chicken parm! This coming from a NJ native that works in..."
"This is one of my new faves in the area, I have just had the thin crust sausage pizza there a couple of times, but very good, great crust, fresh..."
Randy Neary
"Amazing gem!. This is my new favorite pizza place. Amazing traditional meatballs, thin crust wood fire pizza.....this place is a real..."
Facebook User
"Shut the Front Door!. I've actually never used that expression, before, however, this time, I felt it was warranted. Wow! Tried the Quattro Formaggi...."
RA
"Great..."
Marty Guinn
"Easily the best pizza in the area, great atmosphere, great people. this is what pizza its supposed to taste..."
Steve J
"Pie was great...don't get the salad. The regular New York style pie was awesome, they use great ingredients and the dough rocks. The salad was brown..."
Lajini
"Very very good. If you like thin crust pizza that's light and not greasy you will love Tivoli's. Ingredients are fresh! Dinning in is nice and..."
MSUalum
"Awesome. I would advise this to anyone looking for a very fun, and friendly pizza resturaunt. It was the best homemade pizza I have ever..."
"Good food, reasonable prices, great staff! I travel for work and this is one of the most personable and pleasent experiences I've had at a small town..."
Aaron Patrick
"All the food I've had has been top notch! Especially chicken and greens sandwich is so delicious and the chicken riggies are delicious and you get a..."
Bill Briggs
"The pizza and antipasto were both excellent. Same people - new menu and new look. Good..."
Anthony Zumpano
"Nice and cool in here, and the pizza is beyond delicious, not like any pizza around..."
Dielle Whiteley
"My favorite pizza place! Best pizza in town awesome..."
Roman Dybacz
"Great food, cold beer, awesome..."
Andrew Buckley
"Pizza is great. And love haven a friendly bar in North..."
Tami L Rolchigo
"The 711 panini..."
Bri Fitzgerald
"Service is impeccable and the food is..."
Alexandra Elizabeth
"Cold Brew + Hot Slice = Something Very Nice..."
Diana Giana
"Food and service were great!!!
Beautiful..."
Samantha Lynn Ionta
"Fast and friendly service. Stopped in on a busy Friday and received a warm welcome from all 3 employees working the front of the pizzeria. Food was..."
Hoffman Dennis
"Another Utica favorite! Amazing pizza! Divine! A must if traveling through! All kinds of food options. Lunches & dinners & quick bites! You've got to..."
Mary Vivenzo
"Love this place! My supervisor always stops here when we are traveling through Utica and this time I tried the Chicken Riggies. I wasn't..."
"Our first experience was a great one. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, small cheese pizza, 20 everything wings, and a large antipasto salad. The..."
Stacey Dunham Stroble
"Last night I ordered a small sausage and peppers. I can't begin to tell you how impressed I was. I arrived too early to pick up so I waited around...."
Dawn Marie
"The food we ordered was honestly the best I've had in a while! We had a large pizza, fried dough bites, sesame wings and garlic knot sliders and..."
Jon Blando
"I am more than impressed with this eatery. The employees were so pleasent. This is going to be my new pizza place. I recommend this for anyone..."
Alicia A Glinton Boyd
"excellent food, very friendly, got the 2 lg with 40 wing special, a cheeses pizza and upside down pizza with a thin crispy crust excellent, wings..."
Gina LaMonte
"Now I know how they got so many great reviews. Great pizza and wings! The owners and people who work there are very personable!
Will definitely be..."
Stephanie Hay
"Best place, best pizza and wings, best..."
Susan Pierce Roberts
"I had the best calzone I've ever had last night at Pie Squared! The crust was perfect, the fillings were fresh and plentiful, and it was really..."
John A. Stemen
"I called in a large sesame chicken pizza, a small plain upside pie, onion rings, and 10 California wings. When I arrived, I was told the sesame..."
Courtney Spatto
"Great pizza, great staff, great great great!!! Definitely our new place for..."
Kelly Fuller
"Every time I go in the food is amazing. Food is hot & delicious & the service is awesome. The guys are so friendly. Hands down best pizza & best..."
Mandi Kline
"Extremely impressed! By far the best we've had. Everything we ordered was fresh and delicious (Blanco Pizza, Antipasto, and boneless wings). I was..."
Justina Lynn Calenzo
"Finally got the chance to try some items from Pie Squared Eatery and my husband and I were very pleased. Hands down the best gluten free pizza ever,..."
Karen Marie Buono
"Another amazing meal by Pie Squared!! No one makes a pizza like they do. Always perfect, every single time we order. Thank you guy's so much for..."
Jennifer Lattimer
"Best pizza place in the area! Always great food and great service!..."
Ana Richardson
"The upside down pizza ( sauce on top ) is excellent . Nice crispy crust just the way I like it..."
John R Fava
"Ordered spagetts & meatballs, and a sesame chicken pizza. Both were delicious! 1st time there & will be ordering again. Friendly staff as well! Was..."
Anthony Valentine Rivizzigno III
"Just had our first pizza from here and it was cooked to perfection and tasted awesome! The sesame wings were outstanding! Best I’ve ever had!..."
James Chubbuck
"I live down the street from Pi Squared so I'm a frequent customer and I've gotta say these guys have never failed. Incredible service and pizza...."
Max Darman
"We've been ordering from Pie Squared for about a year now and we have always had delicious and fantastic food. It's always fresh and hot. I totally..."
Jennifer Lattimer
"This pizza changed my life!! Literally!
I was on the road with a couple friends, busking in the street. Anthony had just opened Pie Squared and..."
Rebecca
"I was in town on business and stopped in to check it out. Anthony, the owner was very friendly and helpful. Despite being very busy and no apparent..."
Greg Burns
"I've been blown away by every new item I try from their menu. The very best pizza in Utica and beyond. Every specialty pie is out of this world. I..."
Phil Farda
"Love the variety of wings. Pizza is pretty good. Customer service is amazing. Sometimes they're just too busy. But on more than one occasion def..."
Jesse Kayachith
"The food is absolutely delicious! I have eaten the same upside down pizza for many many years...i just found my new favorite! The grilled wings are..."
Bev Piccione
"Hands down Best Pizza and Wings in Utica, NY!!!! Almost every week I have to get the wings and pizza here. 5 star service and 5 star food! The staff..."
"Omg the pizza and wings from this place are amazing. The prices are very reasonable compared to other places around. LG and 40 only $42.99. Will be..."
Mike L
"I gotta honestly say for a small local pizzeria their food ROCKS!! i had their steak sub that was OUT OF THIS WORLD! And their prices were stupid..."
Patrick Michael Moccaldi
"Love the fish dinners & meatball..."
Regina Thornton
"Best pizza around, been coming here for..."
Mackenzie Dwyer
"Once again my guys at Tony's come through , only place i will order from. Food is always hot, fresh and the staff is always friendly. I highly..."
"My pizza was fantastic thick crust what I like,and the service was excellent people there were friendly better then any pizza joint I've ever been in..."
Karen Murray
"I love their pizza. We are having it..."
Audra Longo
"Grate pizza and speicals all the time check them out on..."
"Excellent homegrown Italian pizza. Reminds me of Bolognese pizza.
But most importantly, REASONABLE prices and their wings are just as good as the..."
Jon Fredric West D.M.A.
"Old school pizzeria with pretty big slices. Reasonably priced. Good..."
J
"Food was good... Staff could've been more friendly but I still give it an 9 out of..."
Don D
"My son and I went there today as he had gone there every Friday when he was working in the area. The meal was excellent the portions were fantastic...."
Jean Marshall
"Stopped here yesterday for lunch, the rice balls were great and seem to be uncommon in most pizzerias in central NY so they were definitely a nice..."
Geoffrey Perkins
"Love this place it's sad to know they are closing , nice family and the food and service is always good..."
"Read the reviews online, and the Internet really doesn’t lie. This pizzeria was FN amazing. We came to Utica for a concert and looked for a good..."
Tom Schwensfeir
"My friend and I were staying in Utica and the hotel we stayed at had a restaurant that was closed, so we ordered pizza from here and it was amazing...."
Michael Crowley
"First time there and I ordered a small sausage pizza and it was definitely in my top 5 pizza places. Will make it a point to stop there anytime I am..."
Darrell Ennis
"We just got our pizza ordered from Utica to Atlanta GA, omg it's like I'm home in Utica, it's expensive to order but well worth it. I'm in heaven so..."
Tabatha J Davis Jones
"The best pizza that I can find in the area and it's not close. They are unreal with service, with quality, and sheer authenticity. Come here once and..."
David Downing
"Even after gone 20 yrs- this pizza is BOMB!!!!!!!! Only thing I miss about NY - the pizza!! Well~ the people..."
Jim Robinson
"Passing through Utica and found this pizza place - Best Pizza ! Thank you - staff super friendly..."
Stacy Middleton Ewing
"Fantastic pizza, most stop in Utica, worth getting off the thruway for if passing..."
Mark Rizzolo
"This place and pizza never changes same great pizza decade after decade. I remember the place even before it moved to the current location in a..."
Michael LeClair
"The best pizza I have ever had. I won't buy from anyone..."
Pat Meyers
"The best sausage pizza we have ever had! Loved the crust and how they layer it.
Got the rigatoni and antipasto to go
We will be back. My..."
April Blasier Beckman
"Whats to say,been coming here..."
DonandDenise Johnson
"By far, my most favorite pizza in the Mohawk Valley, They've cornered the market on taste and being unique from other styles of pizza - that being..."
Jeannie Borgia-Wolcott
"Omg!!! Omg!!! My daughter and I stopped (at the recommendation of a friend) on our way to Rochester. Safe to say we will be working this into our..."
Greg Amorosi
"They always make the pie fresh!
They give the best in all they..."
Pamela Flagler
"Classic staple in Utica, I've loved their pizza since I was a kid. Used to be you couldn't find a better or even comparable upside down pizza. But..."
Paige W
"O'Scugnizzo's has been a favorite of our family for decades. Stopped in to get bake-at-home pizzas for football Sunday. The chef cut our pizzas to..."
Shark Man
"It's a family favorite! Whenever we're back in town visiting we always have to get dinner at O'Scugnizzo. Their pizza is the best, and the staff is..."
Shannon McNamara
"Great pizza and great service! The pizza is unlike other pizzas you may have tried. Totally worth a..."
Ilyssa Roberts
"I use to live in Utica, and came to visit a family member. I live in Washington, DC — To this day, no better pizza spot. I’ve been to many: this..."
Irvin Bohac
"Always heard about it, never got a chance to get there until now. We had garlic pizza, wings and fries. All very good. Hey, these guys have been..."
"Typical normal functioning Little Ceasars. No complaints. Food was good enough, service was good enough, wait was little enough; can't ask for much..."
Paige
"Heath W(cashier)who took my order( 2 boxes of italian cheese bread) She was friendly and kind, also she was accurate when processing my..."
Bayside ty
"My family and I went to Utica to visit. We went to this little caesars and asked for 4 fresh pizzas. They gave no complaint. The cashier was even so..."
"They never fail to please me. From the pizza and wings down to their fish fry, and let's not forget the treats its all very delicious. Yum yum. I..."
Ann Marie Zayas
"I order here almost daily for lunch , They deliver and the food is ALWAYS consistent and great! best wings and pasta fagoli in..."
Andria Simpson
"1st time trying it & it was amazing! Kids said it is now their fav & only pizza place they will ever..."
Hayfa Saleh
"Just stopped in and had some Pasta Fagioli. Homemade!!! It was recommended by the gentlemen behind the counter and their service was wonderful...."
Francesca Magro
"My family ordered 3 of the lasagna specials tonight for dinner, omg it was delicious!!!! Perfect for a Sunday..."
Meghan Brown
"Yum, since day 1! Moved away years ago but still my first stop when returning home to..."
Bill Brucker
"Best pizza restaurant in the town. Love it! Amazing service and amazing..."
John Zammiello
"The bonuses of shopping/eating local are never ending!! I was here for lunch and when I got back to my office, I discovered that I had left my purse..."
"My boyfriend and I came here for an early dinner and Gordon was our server. He was awesome, very attentive and informative and a joy to have as a..."
Janey Lacanilao
"Love this place! We've been coming here for years. Denise has been our server since Day 1. We always leave feeling full and satisfied. Love the..."
Lori Nelson Lombardi
"Food , wine �, dessert were awesome. Our server Denise was AWESOME � along with Orlando. This is our 3rd time here & has been outstanding every..."
Susan Ritter Rochefort
"I would recommend our awesome waitress Terra like the Tiramisu. So personable and we had a fun time always enjoy our time..."
Dennis Bojo
"I’ve never been to a restaurant where the manager was so involved in our experience. I really appreciated all of the concern for my boyfriend and..."
Ruby Reyes
"Had one of the best italian meals ever. Jordan and Travis did an extraordinarily great job. Will most definitely come back because of her..."
Donovan Niemiec
"I came over the weekend with my family for dinner and had a great time. Our server Luc was very kind and offered excellent service all evening. I'll..."
Michael Dedvukaj
"Great Service, Great food!! Love this place. Our waitress, Terra, was amazing!!..."
Amy Bosco Bojo
"Great service! Emily was our waitress and very attentive. The food took awhile, but she kept us updated constantly. Food was delicious (they're..."
Jamie Sizemore
"September 2021 - family style dinner. My 6yr old daughter wanted to eat here for her birthday. She loves the spaghetti and Meatballs. The thin pizza..."
Brian D
"SO MUCH FOOD!!! 😋👌🏾 Family Style is an understatement 😂. Very friendly staff. The ambiance is amazing. You will want to walk around the..."
Leo Swilling
"Our group came and had a great experience! Our server Denise was awesome and the food amazing!! Family style. They severed our group of 30 with a..."
Samantha Corrion
"We booked a family dinner for 40 guests 2 days before our meeting date. With the assistance of very friendly staff a preset menu was created to..."
Suzanne Ujj
"This was our first time dining at Buca di Beppo. Great experience. We had Denise as our server. She was so sweet and helpful. She kept checking..."
"Typical normal functioning Little Ceasars. No complaints. Food was good enough, service was good enough, wait was little enough; can't ask for much..."
Paige
"Heath W(cashier)who took my order( 2 boxes of italian cheese bread) She was friendly and kind, also she was accurate when processing my..."
Bayside ty
"My family and I went to Utica to visit. We went to this little caesars and asked for 4 fresh pizzas. They gave no complaint. The cashier was even so..."
"An excellent Italian pizza joint. I wish I could get up that way more to stop..."
jjawin118
"Extremely good NY style pizza. excellent service. Good prices. If you’re in the area I’d recommend..."
Jake Baisley
"Food is ok, prices are up. Mary is the best. Wasn't for her I never..."
William Williams
"Their pizza is wonderful, as well as the rest of their menu. A gem in..."
J P
"I travel all the time, I live in Rochester, NY and by far this is the best Pizza I have ever had. The dough is grilled and not half done. I need to..."
"Lukins rocks ! MR. Monkey loves it there ! Great staff - cool space - excellent pizza - and what a crowd..."
Scott Sterling
"The best employees and fantastic food. We come all the way from Syracuse and it's worth the drive!!! The calzone was delicious and big enough for 2..."
Rebecca Jones
"Incredible wings. Char-broiled honey-garlic, and the works. Margherita pizza was on point too. Great service, beer selection and drinks. Will be..."
Kevin Chudyk
"I go to Lukins every time I get time to go out. By far my favorite place around here, finally somewhere on Varick St where you can sit down watch..."
Chris Shephard
"Cozy place. Very friendly, helpful and attentive staff... food was great. We're put there for grandsons hockey games.
We tried a little of..."
Chuck Salerno
"Top notch service and amazing food with a wide variety of options. Great atmosphere too! Makes you want to try everything on the..."
Howard Potter
"Great place ,great food ,great staff keep up the great..."
Mike Buczek
"Great food great service. Especially the works wings and The pineapple upside down drink was to die..."
Darlene Lowe
"First time there before saranac great pizza loaded fries were awesome great atmosphere will be stopping in..."
Leland Lasher
"Busy night service was slow but the two girls working were doing their best. I think for a Saturday night during football season there should have..."
Robert Murphy
"I'll be honest, every time I've been here it's following the Boilermaker so you could probably feed me close to anything. But in my experience the..."
Cody Hatch
"Great food and great prices. Their pizzas are..."
Wyatt Madej
"I eat here every week for lunch. Amanda is a very capable bar tender and provides stellar customer service. The food here is fair priced and exceeds..."
James Mitchell
"The food is excellent! There's always a great band playing there and the bartenders make you feel at home. A great place for lunch business meetings..."
Joe Sweet
"Awesome food and great staff friendly and clean..."
"Good old Palermo! Only place open late for Pizza in Utica. Prices reasonable, food is delicious! The place is clean, service is friendly and..."
Brad Cornette
"Best wings in town! I've been ordering from Palermo's for over 20 years now and I am very rarely disappointed with anything I order.
Great selection...."
David M.
"Good flavored hot subs, best meatball mozzarella subs in the area. Pizza has robust, crispy crust buttered lightly with zesty sauce. Usually fast..."
Cyrax Saibot
"Superb is the hands that makes the crust wow what an infamous flavor like no other truly magnificent pizza..."
"Stopped by this place on my delivery route out in Utica. My boss recommended this place so we stopped by. Nice size thin slices. Crispy crust, I’ll..."
Andrew Vasquez
"Ordered a purple cow and a cold cheese. Great pizza. Purple cow is genius. But for the love of god cut the two slices apart next time so I don’t..."
Free Lunch
"One of my favorite local pizzerias the Purple Cow wings are a must and very unique but make sure to ask them to char grill them. They make a chicken..."
Citizen Kane
"I ordered from Slice Pizzeria for the office staff today. Such a great experience from order to pick up. We enjoyed trying the different things...."
Sheridan Mish
"Would be 5 stars but after recieving my order of purple cow wings i open the tray to dry regular fried wings with sauce on the side. Seems they dont..."
Gavin Butler
"Updated:So maybe you have never had the Utica pizza with Cheese on the bottom of the sauce. ( I originally called it Tomato Pie... Whoops ), This is..."
"Pizza is always good. Always tastes the same, which is good. Honestly I'm a little sad. I came from California and always heard NY pizza was the..."
Jay Burrows
"Online ordering is easy. Delivery was quick and the order was fresh. The pizza is on par with any "pizza shop" around. Very..."
HUBBABUBBA DOOPYDOOP
"The best makers of the pizza-makers there are. I thank them, because we’re all just loving pizza. These utica employees though, are simply..."
Jules R
"I go there every so often and I do really like it but... I think I was overcharged first thing in the morning. The girl working wasn't friendly at..."
Worldwide Darts
"fast delivery with an update on their website as you can see when it's coming and when it will be there also when it left Dominos. Great delivery..."
Jon
"This was my first time ever having Domino’s pizza and it was better than I expected. The sauce has a spicy, bit of tang, flavor to it. The toppings..."
"Used pizza portal tonight for dinner. Pizza was hot, fresh and loaded with cheese and pepperoni. Crust was soft but held up well, slightly chewy...."
Lolly Goose
"I am shocked that Little Caesars has a deep dish style pizza. It is a Hot-N-Ready for $8 with one topping (but I added two toppings each). It was..."
Muhammed Elgammal
"I have been to a lot of locations. This particular one cooks their pizza with a consistent full crust. Not sure why other locations cannot do the..."
Geoff Charbeneau
"There's a great bunch of kids working here. A $5 Hot-N-Ready is just a $5 Hot-N-Ready. What you need to order here is a deep-dish ultimate supreme...."
GnatGnutz
"First time using the pizza portal! It was interesting. No wait unlike the pizza hut down the street. Order on the app and was told about the pizza..."
"Typical normal functioning Little Ceasars. No complaints. Food was good enough, service was good enough, wait was little enough; can't ask for much..."
Paige
"Heath W(cashier)who took my order( 2 boxes of italian cheese bread) She was friendly and kind, also she was accurate when processing my..."
Bayside ty
"My family and I went to Utica to visit. We went to this little caesars and asked for 4 fresh pizzas. They gave no complaint. The cashier was even so..."
Cynthia Rodriguez
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes