Sluurpy
Reset

11 restaurant menus in %{citta}, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)

Cuisine

Dietary restrictions

Meals

Structure

Dishes

The best Restaurants in West Sayville ranking of December 2024

11 restaurant menus in West Sayville, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Claws Seafood Market
80/100 (1115 ratings)
Browse the menu
Quick Bites
Restaurants
Seafood
Seafood
American
American
Dinner
Lunch
Lobster
Crab
Scallops
Fish & chips
Clams
Oyster
Lobster Roll
Fish
Shrimp
Sit down
American
Seafood
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"First time visiting this location to try the lobster rolls. Must say, I was impressed. The double ‘Naked’ roll was portioned perfectly and the..."
Michael O'Brien
"First time here, lobster rolls are very good, lots of lobster meat, and the baked clams (2 per order) are delish. Outdoor seating available (no..."
Vanessa J Herman
"Love love love !!! The staff was super friendly we ordered the double lobster roll and I think it’s probably one of the best ones I’ve ever had..."
Natalia Alexander
"Amazing seafood market with the freshest seafood on long island. Super fresh seafood and chill patio vibe.. Eat in with cheap and tasty meals. Best..."
Fronimakis Anastasia
"The market has lots of variety and the lobster rolls are outstanding. Don’t order the onion rings because they no longer offer those (that’s what..."
Jennifer Wenzell
"Cool spot in Sayville. Has a cool outdoor dining area with a little creak embedded. Food was pretty good. We had lobster rolls, fish and chips , New..."
Jameson Chen
"Great local spot that is becoming more and more popular. Have dined here 4 times already. The prices have gone up but that is expected in COVID..."
Foodie Chopin
"Decent prices for good seafood. Clam strips were actually good sized, oysters are locally harvested and fresh, shrimp cocktail were jumbo sized for..."
Wil Yumz
"Great place great food. Was able to get all my Christmas Eve fish in one place for a good..."
Richard Sabatino
"Always to crowded in summer to be bothered being it's so small to park and getting to cold be sitting out in open but good prepared fish food at..."
Mark Bregman
"Got two lobster rolls with fries, one shrimp cocktail, one side of Cole slaw, two soft drinks for about $60... Very good value... Food was very good...."
George Bassplayer
"Claws is an incredible no frills spot. Lobster rolls, soft shelled crab sandwiches, king crab legs... Eat it all while hanging out with tons of..."
M B
"The naked lobster roll! Yummmmmm! Excellent the 2 times we've come here. Clam chowder had good flavor but was in desperate need of more clams and..."
Diane Ramos
"I purchased locally caught fish from Claws a few days ago. It was my first time in the store. So far, I have only cooked the swordfish - and I have..."
Katherine D'Abadie
"Always fresh, and great selection. And reasonable! The $20 lobster rolls are not bad, but could use a little clarified butter for flavor. The clam..."
Guy Smith
"Got the lobster roll (double) and although it was pricey it was well worth it. The fries it came with were delicious as well. Side note I did have to..."
Vinny DeVita
"The OG lobster roll was super delicious, will definitely go back to try different..."
Salman Hamirani
"Reasonably priced crab legs, very delicious. Make sure you get the brick of butter from them..."
maddoc31
The Shed Restaurant
83/100 (1078 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
Bar
Bar
Pub
Brunch
Drinks
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Sit down
Bar
Gift Cards Available
Parking Available
Highchairs Available
Full Bar
Free Wifi
Accepts Credit Cards
Non-smoking restaurants
Dog Friendly
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Private Dining
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Wine and Beer
Drinks
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
South Shore Dive
82/100 (892 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Bar
Pub
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Brunch
Buttermilk Fried Chicken Bites
Breakfast
Sangria
Bloody Mary
Cocktail
Steak & Eggs
Beer
Brunch Burger
Juice
Meat and Cheese
Fish and Chips
Chicken and Waffles
Chicken blt Sandwich
Mac and Cheese and Chicken Wings
Baked Mac & Cheese
Giant Pretzel
French Onion Burger
Spiked Hot Cocoa
Sixpoint Resin Double IPA
Bar
Pub
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Brunch
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"A very nice and small dining room with outdoor seating available. I came here with my parents for dinner here and we’ve also been here for brunch..."
Daniel Tusso
"Great divish bar, but has amazing cocktails and surprisingly good food. The food menu is limited, but it's great. They rotate specials, and they are..."
Roberto Poo
"Met up with a friend for lunch on a Sunday. Was hoping to get the regular menu...we didn't realize it was brunch. We were not disappointed. We both..."
Virginia Nanni
"A good spot here for sure! I feel like it’s a sleeper. Not many know yet how good it is. Food was great. Really enjoyed our meal here. Chicken and..."
Peter Montalvo
"The food and drinks were delicious. Our server was very attentive and fun. It wasn't a night to check out the backyard seating area. Will definitely..."
Cristi Aiello
"Decent drinks. Good selection of LI brews. Not the biggest menu but food was delicious. Wings were mediocre- not enough flavor. Pretzel was good...."
John Halter
"I love this place! I first went when they first opened and the owner was hanging lights in the outdoor area. Pretty nice guy! I'm a vegetarian so I..."
Sarah Johnson
"Really cool spot. Fun alternative to The Shed for Brunch. Took my my friends and it was a hit. 3 of us had the Churro Waffle w/Chicken with Frose’s..."
Rodino Janowski
"Jess is always incredible 👍🏽 so we had another great night on the deck. Lily the hostess made sure the outside seats were dry..... Dave March..."
Mark Gamble
"South shore dive is one of the only places I come to alone whenever I want to enjoy an evening. Bobby and Jules were amazing and so accommodating it..."
Kelsey Herrera
Kingston's Clam Bar
80/100 (858 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Seafood
Bar
American
Seafood
American
Gluten Free Options
Bar
Vegetarian Friendly
Gluten Free Options
Dinner
Lunch
Tapas
Shrimp
Oysters on Half Shell
Tacos
Fish and Chips
Steamers
French Fries
Cakes
Lobster
Fried Shrimp
Fish
Salad
Baked Clams
Chocolate cake
Stuffed Shrimp
corona
Crab
Clams on Half Shell
Seafood salad
Clams
Cold Lobster Roll
Crab cakes
Oyster
Clams and Oysters on the Half Shell
Calamari
Salmon Garden Salad
Mussels
Garlic Shrimp Roll
Tuna
Mussels in Blueberry and Lavender Broth OH My
Seafood Chili
Calamares
Burger and fries
Strawberry Mojito
Chicken Caesar
Lobster Roll
Sit down
American
Seafood
Bar
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Full Bar
Outdoor Seating
Takeout
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Fabulous little local seafood & atmospheric gem. The lobster bisque is phenomenal! Great place to go around sunset even during the week for a quick..."
LilBella Jax
"Our lobster rolls we good and fresh but chicken was really tough and chewy. Strawberry mojitos had no..."
yana_shwal
"10/10 would recommend! The lobster roll was delish and the oysters couldn’t be fresher. The only thing they need to work on is their mixed drinks,..."
Michele Stokes
"I should’ve had the lobster roll and salad because that’s my favorite. As usually they say new place new taste, so l went in with 1 order stuff..."
Nb “Unlimited Everything”
"Stopped in while on the Island visiting family this summer, Food and Atmosphere was so GOOD!! Hubby had the steamed clams and said they were so good...."
Jennifer Susko
"The lobster was perfect, sides are delicious, and the drinks were excellent. They have some of my favorite garlic bread. So perfect with their..."
Jacqueline Rowe
"The best lobster roll 🦞 and calamari. Cook to perfection 😋. The best long Island ice tea and pain killer drinks !! Highly recommend it!..."
ana lainez
"This place did not disappoint! Amazing food, nice waterfront view, and friendly service. We ordered the fried calamari with the Kung Pow dipping..."
Asli Pisano
"Excellent view of the inlet. Not a long wait to be seated and the servers are attentive. Excellent menu, plenty of good choices. Fish and chips are..."
Samantha Vogel-Hespos
"Great food, really nice and friendly staff. Great music. What else can you ask..."
Enarzis Sagastizado
Hoi Ming Restaurant Incorporated
85/100 (350 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
Vegetarian Friendly
Chinese
Asian
Vegetarian Friendly
Dinner
Lunch
Shrimp
Cantonese
"By far the best Chinese on Long Island! Ask for Edmund as your..."
Chris N
"The food is great, the service very friendly and the prices are very reasonable. We ordered the Moo Shu Pork and Shrimp lo mein (I get no veggies..."
Amy P
"Authentic Old School Chinese! No Fusion just great food like it used to be. Awesome Service, Low Paparazzi level. Thank You Phil, John, And the crew..."
Kev Good
"Classic Chinese food. The food is consistently great, the cocktails are generously made and I’ve known the guys who work here since I was a..."
Arthur Nixon
"Some of my friends have been coming here for over 30 years. Nice, older hometown place. Very cozy and fun at the bar. The house specials are the..."
Robin Hoff
"Very good food. The staff is very nice and they are all well dressed. Definitely not your run of the mill Chinese take out place. They even pack..."
Gareth Warren
"The food and service are phenomenal. Linens on the table and cloth napkins. Plates, glasses, flatware, tablecloths and napkins are always clean. ..."
A F
"One of the best Asian Foods restaurant that I have ever been to. The atmosphere is cozy, great selection and food is fresh and delicious... just from..."
Marie B
"Best Chinese food on Long Island! I've been coming here for 25 years now and new once had a bad meal. The food is delicious! Its truly authentic..."
John Sakitis
"Been coming here since 1974. Excellent service, food and atmosphere. Phil is the best waiter I've ever had. He became a friend over the years. It's..."
Fritz the Cat
"Love eating here! Lunch, Dinner,Late Night Snack. Sit Down or Take Out either way, the Food is OUTSTANDING! The Duck Sauce is AWESOME! Everything..."
Charles Clampet
"I've been here for years the food is amazing its so good that the second day tastes even better. Phil is best waiter he always makes sure you..."
maria abbattista
"Great place! Foods terrific, the entire staff is professional, and friendly! Like a time machine back to the 70's! Great "hot and sour" soup!..."
Fred Masterson
"Hoping they re-open soon- this is THE finest Chinese restaurant . Beautiful interior , white table cloths, food served on silver platters. Amazing..."
Joseph Riley
"Old school Cantonese restaurant white linen table cloths & stainless steel serving dishes with lids. Service is great. Building is old interior is a..."
Deborah
"As a child I went here often with my family and now as an adult I continue to do the same. They make homemade duck sauce and the tea served with..."
beth allen
"What's not to love! For anybody 40 and over, its reminiscent of the Chinese restaurant of your youth. Same people since I was 6 (I'm 48). Food is..."
Robert Johnson
"Missing our favorite restaurant and Phil, Edmund, John and hope you come back 😢 soon. Great staff, great food and it's like coming home. They..."
Eve Kelly
The Nook
84/100 (328 ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
"The Nook is wonderful, eclectic and comfortable. The staff are very helpful and the food is top-notch. One of the few (maybe only) places to get..."
Peter Haynes
"Great "alternative" vibe you don't really see anywhere outside of 90s Greenwich Village. Vegan selection is ample and delicious. Affordable as well...."
Joseph Ruddleston
"Place wasn't what I expected. Food was delicious ( we had 3 different sandwiches and they were each excellent). The table was a little sticky and the..."
Ru Jurow
"J just to say... Wonderful place to enjoy very healthy meals they have gluten-free desserts they have vegan and many other options. That decor just..."
Lulu Bundra
"Nice selection of vegetarian, vegan and gluten free foods as well as meaty, gluten-full paninis, sandwiches, soups, and pizzas made fresh to order by..."
Melissa Molfetto
"Super nice family-like staff. The food is good, and the atmosphere makes you feel like you're in your creative best friends house. There is a piano,..."
Michael O'Brien
"One of the coziest cafes I've been to that really nails the at home vibe. Food was delicious and coffee was great too as a sat in a rocking chair..."
Live Mas
"I got to spend some time here and I must say, I thoroughly enjoyed the food and atmosphere. I was part of a lovely comedy show that featured some..."
Bill Morales
"Great vegan food! Amazing vegan dessert options also, highly recommend the Boston cream donut. Overall great hangout/date spot very retro atmosphere..."
C Yates
"Cute little lunch place. Have only been twice for sandwiches and had the Charlie Brown both times. Very cozy and eclectic. Haven't tried the coffee..."
Katie Hoffmann
"Had a really great experience last night with my family. The man (owner/manager) who helped us was extremely concerned about my sons allergies and..."
The Yoga Shack
"Hungry? Want coffee? Want dessert? They have it all! Such a cute little spot. It's so sad it's hidden but also a blessing because it's not too..."
nerm kad
"Really great place that has vegan comfort foods. Unfortunately they were out of stock of all veg meats and daiya cheez when I went for the first..."
Alecia Moore
"My absolute favorite place to go for lunch. So many different vegan dishes to choose from. My son absolutely Loves their pizza and garlic knots!!!..."
Lara serendipity
"Very nice versatile menu. They have food for vegetarians and vegans and omnivores and gluten-free. Prices are reasonable. Staff is quite welcoming...."
Robin Septon
"Cozy, Eclectic, Delicious fresh baked pastries. French Frie Pizza? Great place to eat some great comfort food or have an espresso with a pastry,..."
Matthew Levine
"I frequent this location, they have a great cold brew, their pizza is good, and their variety in other foods is appealing to all walks of life. The..."
Dan Janosick
"Bring a lot of bucks for tea, vegan cakes, pizza and bring some people to play games with! Bring your own games or enjoy the board games there. Great..."
Andrea Katz
"Being lactose intolerant I hadn't been able to have a good pizza for a decade... until I discovered The Little Nook Cafe. Their lactose-free pizza is..."
Alan
Audrey's Fine Baked Goods
89/100 (233 ratings)
Browse the menu
Dessert
Bakeries
Lunch
Breakfast
Cakes
Cheesecake
Cheesecakes
Wheelchair Accessible
Takeout
Breakfast
Lunch
Mid-range
"Another truly gorgeous and delicious cake by Audrey's. I gave some direction with pics and colors and they couldn't have done better job. It was..."
Catherine Schneider
"I celebrated my graduation yesterday in this gorgeous place. happy to tell that we had a wonderful evening and the venue was indeed one of the..."
Daxton Duncan
"I had a cake for my daughter’s bridal shower made. It was so beautiful and one of the most delicious bakery cakes I’ve ever had. I was extremely..."
Anne Scharfenberg
"I ordered a cake for our wedding last minute and they did an amazing job! It looked beautiful and tasted delicious! I would recommend everyone to use..."
Kimberly Androvich
"Absolutely amazing! Audrey's bakery made this beautiful cake for my baby shower and it looked beautiful and tasted amazing! They were so helpful in..."
Alyvia Lewter
"Ordered cupcakes for a work celebration and they were very accommodating packaging each cupcake separately. The cupcakes were so awesome and we..."
Veronica DuBois
"Bought 2 trays of Holiday cookies, the staff was very pleasant and the cookies were..."
Patrick Metallo
Bluestone Tavern
76/100 (229 ratings)
Browse the menu
Bars & Pubs
Bars & Pubs
Restaurants
Pub
Bar
Pub
American
American
Bar
Dinner
Lunch
Shrimp
Salad
Burger
Bar
Pub
American
Television
Private Dining
Reservations
Seating
Table Service
Serves Alcohol
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"Very friendly staff... Cold drinks... Good food!... Can't go wrong..."
patricia cabaero
"This is my family's go-to place for Friday night dinner. We eat here at least once per month. The food is great, the people are lovely. My toddler..."
Vanessa Bishop
"I met a young lady here on a first date. We had appetizers and wine at a table in the bar area. The waitresses were attentive and the place was very..."
Donald Fitzsimons
"Great Local (more than a) Tavern! Always a treat for food and libations! They went above and beyond with today's SHS HOMECOMING crowd! Thanks to..."
Maxine McMonaco
"Love it here! Love it, love it, love it! Moving out here, I needed a good sports bar. The food is really good and the bar area is good for a decent..."
Jack
"Great beer selection and burgers. Staff were friendly as well. Gets very busy but that's obviously a good sign of their..."
John Scottaline
"The bone-in rib eye is so juicy and delicious, my mouth waters as I write about this. This is definitely a your typical, nice steakhouse you bring..."
pattie hayness
"Great place to spend some time with someone. Food is very good, and so is the..."
Rem Godfrey
"This place amazes me every time we go. The staff are so warm and welcoming. Overall this is just a pleasant place to have some great..."
Keith Kloete
"Everything was delicious. They were very accommodating for a party of 8. The beer selection is pretty good, but they had a few too many IPAs..."
Joseph Cappellino
"Good food. Cosy bar area. Good service. Atmosphere can be loud and cafeteria like. Middle aged cloud and some families. Will..."
Bill Burke
"Nice bar and restaurant separate sections so you have a choice, nice quiet dinner or loud fun at the bar and high tops. Unfortunately the tinplate..."
Bruce Jen
"This is the best place to eat. The chicken tenders and french fries are delicious. Also, my cousin works here so that is a bonus. I love this place..."
Marissa
"Had the sunny side burger and wife had the meatloaf. Both outstanding. Ordered burger rare and it came out cooked to..."
Paul Porrini
The Sunken Sailor
96/100 (106 ratings)
Browse the menu
Bars & Pubs
Restaurants
Bar
Pub
Seafood
American
Bar
Pub
American
Seafood
Scotty's Pub
70/100 ( ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
Poppa Mia's Ice House
70/100 ( ratings)
Browse the menu
Restaurants
Connect with Sluurpy
X
Sign in with Facebook

Sign in with Google

Sign in with Apple

By continuing, you confirm that you accept:
- Privacy policy
- Terms of use