The best Restaurants in Williams Bay ranking of February 2025
16 restaurant menus in Williams Bay, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"This was our second visit to Pier 290 and it was fantastic! The food was excellent (the bone in pork chop was to die for) and the atmosphere was..."
Olivia Lenski
"My immediate impression was that this restaurant was a lot bigger than it looked – seems like there were somehow more people in this restaurant..."
Dan
"I love Pier 290 and have been coming here since they opened. By far one of the best places on the lake. Atmosphere is number 1 of all places on the..."
Megan I
"Pier 290, Gages Marine, has the best "Boat Sharing" program. It works like Time Sharing...you pay a set fee, Gages
Reserves your time and Boom,..."
Traveling O
"Service was great. Our waitress took our orders and had drinks in our hand super fast. Food came out quickly. A bit pricey for the quality and..."
Renee N
"Excellent staff and awesome view of the lake. Food was excellent. Did I mention the staff was great and very attentive? Beach area was fantastic,..."
Robert Duchow
"This was a great place to celebrate new years eve. Service was excellent and our meal was great. Great selection of drinks. This place is pricey but..."
"For starters, along with the amazing calamari, bread, oil, herbs and Parmesan, the server was very personable and knowledgeable about the menu. The..."
Susan Foley Smolarek
"Always love the food, service and atmosphere at Cafe Calamari. Prime rib on Fridays is awesome, Chilean sea bass also very good. Their house salad..."
Mike Quernemoen
"Another great meal at Cafe Calamari. Delicious food and top notch service. Place was packed of course and we got to visit with many tables filled..."
Robert Pope
"The absolute best restaurant best service best food reasonable prices great atmosphere..."
Debbie Mott
"All of the food was excellent. I reccommend getting the calamari of course! Also, the drinks are amazing, I recommend the blackberry mule and..."
Nicole Schreiber
"Love everything from the white lights outside to the Italian aviance inside. The food,, service and drinks were fantastic. Highly recommend and..."
Lou Ann Agnew-Chambers
"The food was excellent and the service was excellent beautiful on the lake the house dressing is to die for I’ll definitely go back..."
Gina Spanola Sandowski
"Great place to eat!! Great atmosphere, food, wait staff and view of the Geneva..."
Michael Camilli
"Never not well attended. Every night of the week, a solid crowd. Bartender knew the menu and the drinks, food always well presented and delicious...."
William Hunt
"This was our first time dining at Cafe Calamari ... we loved it !! Ambience and decor was great .. atmosphere, waitstaffabs service was top notched..."
Holly Hill Murawski
"Fabulous night with Nate and Nick at the bar!! Professional bartenders who make the evening especially enjoyable!! Plus the "bar menu" is a hidden..."
Bob O'Neill
"Celebrated my birthday last night. There were 5 of us & all our food was excellent! I had the Sea Bass & it was so delicious. Our waiter was so..."
Judy Hafstedt
"We came by across this place by accident and I'm so glad we did. The ambiance, service everything was amazing. Best Rockefeller oysters I've ever..."
Nina G
"Love, Cafe Calamari restaurant in Williams Bay, WI … whether indoors/outdoor patio has an ambiance atmosphere you’ll want to dine -in &..."
kristina rigdon
"It's always a good night dining at Cafe. I love their scallops with pasta. Salads are..."
H V
"My husband and I had eloped yesterday and we went there for supper. We were treated so amazing by all of the staff and patrons. Tonya was an amazing..."
Danielle Shircel
"We went to dinner on a recommendation and we're looking to going back already. The staff were so attentive and professional that it was more than we..."
Christopher Bryant
"The food here was mouth watering. And the staff wers super friendly and accommodating to my group of..."
"The best food in Williams Bay! I would recommend this restaurant ..great food..friendly staff! Worth the drive for us from..."
Bev Bohlman
"Amazing food, amazing view, really good IPA’s. Worth the 40 minute drive and definitely will be going..."
Whitney Meisner
"Food was great we had the tuna sandwich and the brisket sandwich. Scott the bartender was awesome! Will definitely be visiting..."
Trish Szopinski
"Stopped by to watch football while in the area. Good beer, good pizza. Shift change so tipped 2 waiters. I would definitely go again. Fun place with..."
Gary Stachewicz
"The service was excellent and the food was over-the-top delicious!!! I think the food we were served was the best we've had in the Geneva Lake area..."
Barb Samuels
"Top notch drinks, especially the brandy old fashioned is big and delicious, staff is attentive and friendly, fabulous place with a great view of the..."
Steve Jazz Jeskewitz
"The chicken rice soup is phenomenal!!
The service was great! We also loved the fresh popcorn! Fun place! We will be..."
Erica Lynn
"The food was delicious and reasonable prices. The staff was very attentive and the view was..."
Tim Allen
"This place is worth going to for the experience and the atmosphere was pretty good. The service was good as well and the views were alright of the..."
Chris Parent
"Another solid stop at Harpoon Willie's Deck. The blackened ahi tuna was finished just right. The pulled pork, cheddar burger, guacamole burger, and..."
Joel Reyenga
"Good, fresh, and flavorful food. Good service. I'm from out of town; but, I'd return on my next visit. And, my 8 and 6 year old boys enjoyed the..."
Daniel Pugh
"Ordered take out via the Toast app. So ordering was extremely easy. Food was prepared on time and everything we ordered was very good. The inside of..."
Michael True
"another great Wisconsin bar. they have a nice dark corner you can go cry into your beer and no one will laugh at..."
"We stayed at the Abbey for a girls spa weekend. Being from Chicago, we wanted to try something different for breakfast and the front desk suggested..."
Margie Gotti
"Friendly staff, great food, fresh fruit, loved the fun decor! Highly recommend this place if your in..."
Sarah Darling
"We've never been to this town so we asked a guy putting his boat in the water where can we have breakfast and this is where he told us to come. It..."
Kevin Kilmurry
"Daddy Maxwell has the best Eggs Benedict in the country! I love this dish & try it everywhere I go, but none can touch Daddy Maxwells. Only on..."
Amy Marsico
"Daddy Maxwell's in very unique and has preserved the authenticity through their food, space, friendly and family atmosphere. It was so good, that I..."
Maria Barreto
"A fantastic place with awesome people. We only had the coffee and doughnuts, but the service was exceptional and people were friendly. I would..."
David Fricke
"Love the place. Great food and excellent service! Would recommend going there. I love their breakfast..."
Gail Wolfgram
"Fantastic homemade deliciousness!!! Very cute and eclectic atmosphere! Great service! The french batter pancakes were to die..."
Jina Jacklin Hoffmann
"Great food and charming place to eat breakfast or..."
Mary Sikorski
"Hands down the best Eggs benedict, homemade Granola & service around. We will drive almost 2 hours one way on a Sunday morning just to have..."
Megan Miller Mynatt
"Went there for breakfast, delicious homemade meal, can’t wait to go..."
Pati Creech
"Great breakfast menu. Full Nine is a must - pancake burrito with eggs, bacon and cheese!! Nice big cups of coffee. Very small cozy place. Used to..."
A Anderson
"Very cute brunch spot. The food is very good and the staff is very..."
Regina Blum
"I ordered the Black Russian burger and , boy was it good!. A nice thick burger done to medium with sour cream and sliced black olives. The fries..."
Bruce Tillotson
"My dad Tom has been taking me here since I was a wee little boy. The food has been delicious for all these years and the staff are always amazingly..."
Scott S
"Very tasty breakfast and fantastic atmosphere! I will definitely be eating here again. Wide variety of a menu and the prices are very fair. Great..."
Matthew Blake
"One of the best diners ever! Breakfast, lunch, soooo good. Homemade pies are amazing..."
Scott F Wilson
"The story, food and service are amazing. Expect a wait on busy mornings, especially during tourist seasons. Built to model the yerkes observatory and..."
"Really enjoyed this place. Amazing food and a very “homey” environment. Has that authentic vibe and the staff was very friendly. The various..."
Amar Pandya
"If you are in the mood for a good burger, which I often am, you need look no further than The Assembly. It's not much to look at from the outside,..."
Brian Harrison
"A favorite for Saturday/ Sunday breakfast huevos rancheros (they're the BEST here!!! So we travel from IL) and don't miss their bloody mary bar! We..."
Courtney Palmer
"Love this gem. Great food and service. I loved everything. Expecially the drinks. Excellent..."
Missy Tenzer
"Very Delicious bloody Marys and Margaritas. The food explodes in flavor, 5 stars. I live in Lake Geneva and this is a nice gold mine for me. Lake..."
"We looooove this place! Best family business ever! Ice cream is delicious and they have so many great flavors to choose from.... It's hard to pick..."
Susan Gaston
"Amazing ice cream, and the gentleman working was very kind and accommodating...."
Zoe Dittman
"I love this place! Great ice cream, great..."
Kimberly Scheer
"Great sandwiches and ice cream! Very friendly..."
Rob Kitto
"Nice little parlor with good vegan ice cream! Very friendly..."
Nakita Daffodil Jensen
"Our favorite ice cream shop!!!! We make it our first stop and last stop when we are in Williams Bay! The owners are..."
Janet Kolb Mulvey
"Great people, great owner operator, friendly and..."
Michael Rohleder
"This is probably my favorite ice cream shop in the area. I swear I get withdrawals when they're closed in the off season. Their prairie dirt sundae..."
Grant Parry
"Very friendly family owned place they have snacks ice cream and have sandwiches that are made fresh. The crab salad is made in house and very good...."
Brian Palmer
"My family and I LOVED this eatery! The sandwiches had more than enough meat on them, and the walking taco was AMAZING! I also highly recommend the..."
Nicole Dabros
"The ice cream here is fantastic, and the staff work really hard to be friendly, patient, and accommodating, even when the place is overflowing and..."
Beth Anderson
"I really enjoyed this local establishment. Good food selection for summer time enjoyment. Lots of ice cream flavors. I got two Chicago..."
Bob Graham
"Excellent!!!
Their sandwiches are superb!! The ice cream - out of this world. Treat yourself - go..."
Paul Martin
"Love this little shop! Their ice cream was amazing as were the cone choices. I love the tie dye shirts that had wide sales. The employees were..."
Luvmarley Tahara (luvmarley2645)
"Although it felt a little weird with sheets of plastic up, this review is posted just after mask mandates were lifted, so I understand in this..."
"My fiancé and I found this little gem today while out and about - and it’s absolutely adorable!! We ordered delicious sandwiches to eat at the..."
Lori Schroeder Johnson
"Love this place! Delicious healthy sandwiches, soups, salads! Adorable atmosphere, wish it was a little more dog..."
Ruth De Bruyn
"Absolutely love the food, the wines, and the space is fabulous. Exposed brick, sweeping soft chandeliers, and cozy nooks to get lost in...."
Adriane Rose
"Very quaint, comforitable and welcoming! My mom and I had fresh and delicious soups and sandwiches for lunch. The man working there was very friendly..."
Meagan Johnson
"The Green Grocer is one of my favorite places! My now fiancé asked me 4 years ago to be his girlfriend at the Green Grocer while we enjoyed a..."
Brogan Victoria Brogan
"BEAUTIFUL location, food, and people! It's the coziest spot in the area..."
Paige Weslaski
"The Bay Salad is outstanding!!! I could eat this everyday and feel good about..."
Woody Rill
"Just wonderful...plan to have friends come up in near future and spend time visiting The Green..."
Kathleen McCampbell
"Green Grocer is a small Grocery store on main street of Williams Bay. If you're a Weekender, this is good place to get your supplies. Inventory is..."
Traveling O
"Such a great little store that has everything you need. From grabbing a quick sandwich to a salad or juice bar or smoothie. You can find all your..."
Tammy Lawson
"Their sandwiches and juices are excellent. It can be hard to find places with high quality ingredients while traveling but this places offers good..."
Amy J
"Perfect little place to grab a delicious sandwich! The service was quick and the shop is charming. Their sandwiches and smoothies are delicious. We..."
Katie Fiola Jones
"If you are in the Lake Geneva area I highly recommend stopping here for lunch. It's worth the short drive from downtown Lake Geneva and easily rivals..."
Matthew Staub
"Helpful, friendly staff add to the relaxing feel of this little, unique establishment. Excellent wine choices and deli items make living the..."
Donna Graves
"Green Grocer is in Bay Centre Building in Williams Bay. It's a very fine, boutique Grocery Store. Boar's Head Cheese and hand-sliced Meats are..."
Miles ToGo
"Such a cute family-owned store. I was impressed by the variety and selection of organic, keto, and healthy foods like Hippeas and Lily's chocolate! A..."
"Great staff. Great locals. Amazing coffee and food! The Quiche is a..."
Nicole Ileen Didier
"Great place to enjoy my favorite Fava Tea and sit back, relax and listen to great..."
Diane Vey
"A cozy, relaxing place with friendly people. A couple of hours there will spark your inner..."
Mike Felske
"Love coffee, love wine, love food, love art, love friends, love..."
Sandy Johnson
"Stopped in last night. What a comfortable welcoming place! Really fantastic. I was there to do a little gift shopping and found just what i was..."
Thomas Ingold
"Very welcoming, great coffee. Can't wait to go back for an evening of music & wine. Thank you for being in Williams..."
Anthony Ashley
"Had a wonderful time going through the art and handmade crafts. Many things here would make unique birthday and holiday gifts. Wonderful coffee and..."
Gaye O'Keefe
"Great coffee, great wines, local art and music, treats and friendly..."
Tom Powers
"We loved it so much we went twice during the 3 days we were there. Tried another local coffee shop too, but this was our favorite. Looking forward to..."
"Great staff. Great locals. Amazing coffee and food! The Quiche is a..."
Nicole Ileen Didier
"Great place to enjoy my favorite Fava Tea and sit back, relax and listen to great..."
Diane Vey
"A cozy, relaxing place with friendly people. A couple of hours there will spark your inner..."
Mike Felske
"Love coffee, love wine, love food, love art, love friends, love..."
Sandy Johnson
"Stopped in last night. What a comfortable welcoming place! Really fantastic. I was there to do a little gift shopping and found just what i was..."
Thomas Ingold
"Very welcoming, great coffee. Can't wait to go back for an evening of music & wine. Thank you for being in Williams..."
Anthony Ashley
"Had a wonderful time going through the art and handmade crafts. Many things here would make unique birthday and holiday gifts. Wonderful coffee and..."
Gaye O'Keefe
"Great coffee, great wines, local art and music, treats and friendly..."
Tom Powers
"We loved it so much we went twice during the 3 days we were there. Tried another local coffee shop too, but this was our favorite. Looking forward to..."
"Excellent food. We probably order at least once a week and found everything to be fresh and delicious. We have tried burgers, corned beef, gyros,..."
Mary Therese Andrich Lieb
"Delicious food for humans and dogs. Outstanding service and staff dote on..."
Lisa M. Bertotto Schmelz
"Awesome rib eye steak sandwiches! Very friendly customer..."
Julie Lesko
"Great service!Excellent food,had the burger and fries!Will be..."
Ruth Timmerman
"Great food, friendly environment, and reasonably priced! Will definitely be..."
Ryan Cunningham
"Excellent place to eat! The food is amazing and is equally on par with the astounding staff! We happened to go while they had a promotion going and..."
Jacob Blank
"Some friends took us there; never would have found it or tried it ourselves. Fantastic food--Chef Jonathan is talented! Great Sunday brunch options..."
Timothy Prince
"Great looking menu items. The salads and sandwiches we ordered we're very good. Good prices. Nice..."
The Big O
"We enjoy stopping here for Sunday breakfast. We are never disappointed. Had reservations for Mother’s Day with a large group. It was nice that they..."
K A LUECHT
"Best quiche, best omelette, best pancakes... Cannot go wrong with anything on the menu.. highly recommend brunch..."
Gil Ramos
"The ambiance is great, the food was spectacular. Plenty of parking and an outside patio. The prices are affordable. Our server (Elizabeth) was..."
Timothy Bales
"The food was awesome. You can tell they have an actual chef making the food. We had breakfast there and it was all homemade. I would highly recommend..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes