Only tried the banana pudding and the apple crisp pudding. I'm not super into bananas but the banana pudding was still good. The apple crisp stuff is incredible though, if they aren't sold out. The other problem is that what you get is a little inconsistent. Sometimes it's heavier on pudding, other times on the vanilla wafers. I haven't had one heavy on apples yet, but I've had one that had only a single piece of apple. That said it's still good, just not as good. Definitely recommend taking the risk as it's good no matter what.
Five star for Banana pudding. The texture and flavor both are amazing withou too sweet.
Brownie fudge one is ok. Blueberry pie is too sweet for me though.
The shop is not so much crowded when I visited in the late afternoon.
NYC MUST TRY. I personally don’t even eat bananas HOWEVER this banana pudding is amazing. Everyone has their own opinions but I think if you have not tried Magnolia’s Banana Pudding… YOU SHOULD! It’s a perfect snack while roaming around NYC. There are many convenient locations, grab a spoon and enjoy!!
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes