The best Restaurants in Pickerington ranking of February 2025
122 restaurant menus in Pickerington, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"As usual, the employees are wonderful. They are always very attentive and friendly. As for the food, I've NEVER been disappointed in anything I've..."
Diana Divine
"Great service and prices are in line with other venues. Asked for cheese in my scrambled eggs, but the amount was indistinguishable.... Could not..."
Bobby Lynch
"Went for dinner, they had a wait but were very formal about it! Once we were sat our waitress only came to us for our order and our check, our food..."
Maeve Pack
"I ordered grandma meal. Food was warm. Appearance of Sausage little over cooked and slice ham looked like it's the leftover from a slice, that..."
Elva Wright
"Great place for food. The food is always good. The surver was super sweet and took care of us. Cannot say enough about this restaurant. I love the..."
"This is a new experience as Steak and Shake is now contact free inside. Customers order from a kiosk, seat themselves and when the food is ready they..."
Debra Anderson
"I always love the food here. Nice hot fries. I had the hot dog for the first time and I was impressed! Milkshakes are always amazing. Make sure to..."
"We liked the service and the food! The steaks were delicious and the temperature was on point in both our orders (medium-well and medium). The salad..."
Daniela
"The service was really good. We sat at the bar and our server was very polite and attentive. The food was okay/good. My husband asked for a..."
CoCo
"We decided to stop in tonight for a bite to eat. We were not disappointed. We got right in and service was fast. Our waitress made sure we had..."
T Frazee
"The food was good! I've gone a good few times now and the servers are always so helpful and nice. The server I had today was named Kylon, I believe,..."
Sarah Hardy
"This is my dream place. Steaks are alway extra juicy. Butter is the best meals are always tasty here. I always get into this restaurant quarterly or..."
Cynthia O
"Date night at LongHorn is always a catch. The food and drinks here is wonderful. I especially love their Brussel..."
Andrea Hawkins
"The food was delicious, the only problem the server didn't come back & check like she should to see if we needed refills, bit I normally have an..."
Mz Hollywood (Mzholleewud)
"We went to three different restaurants tonight, all of them their kitchens closed at 8, maybe for the holiday? I’m not sure. We were thankful..."
"This gem is located right next to my hotel. Lucky me!! Been there every night I've been in town for various meals and always with a cold Yuengling...."
Dave Assmann
"Good food, good portions, reasonable prices.
We got carnitas dinner which was a big plate of food! Wife and I split the fajitas and it was good. ..."
J Harper 360 Pics
"Sometimes when you think it couldn’t be better this happens !! Guess who came to play !! Bott boys — Jim and Dave … how cool to have some..."
Kim Young
"We come here about once a month. The food is always delicious. I have tried about everything on the menu and no disappointments yet. This particular..."
J
"The server recommended our drink; JD Special. It was perfect! Don't shy away from it, you must try it if you are looking for alcohol. The food was..."
Crystal Valentine
"So after eating here 3 nights in a row, I'd say it's decent, but with a minor complaint or 2. First off the service at the bar is great, they get..."
"My friend and I came here last Friday to pick up dinner for our girls night dinner party. The food was fresh and everything was good. This was..."
Elon Nichols
"David was wonderful and.made fast food feel classy. I had a great experience. We had even drove about 15 mes past our destination to find Long John..."
Laura Murray
"Some fast food places stand out for value, some for quality of the food, and some for customer service. This Pickerington KFC location stands out for..."
atom tarragon
"Got drive through to take to my dad in a medical facility. The drive through attendant was polite the experience was fast and accurate. I would..."
Sara Davis
"Came here for my fish the lines were long. But moved fast my fish was..."
Mz Hollywood (Mzholleewud)
"What a well managed restaurant! I’ve been here twice and both times I’ve had a great experience. The staff is well trained and attentive. Our..."
"We hadn't been to Roosters in a couple of years. We forgot how big their wings are. We ordered 20 for 2 of is. Well we took 12 home. Can you same..."
PS V
"Very popular with families. Dinner prices very reasonable. Excellent service from our waitress. She was very thoughtful and professional. Food was..."
Mike Brue
"I was shocked at how young the staff is....then was shocked at how professional and polite they acted. Hats off to whomever trained these employees. ..."
Eric “Darbo” Darby
"Our server was great, we had a group of 17 that came in! They were able accommodate us with hardly any wait at all. We are not from Ohio and there is..."
Spenser Mendel
"Sat us down quick on a busy Thursday evening after work hours. Food was good. The half salad red rooster seemed bigger than the past but the waitress..."
Jalenna Dudley
"We love Roosters! Their wing sauces are always good. The Nu Killer is their hottest sauce but not so hot 🔥 that you can't enjoy it. The garlic is..."
Ric Shoemaker
"This place is the absolute best. My arteries can no longer eat there as much as I used to but it is good. Hands done the best wings! The sauce is..."
Caesar Salad w Spicy Chicken Double Chicken and a Baked Potato Covered in Black Pepper
Daves Burger with Cheese
Wendy’S Classic Chocolate and Vanilla Frosty Desserts
Wendy’S Coffee Drinks Hot Coffee Cold-Brew and Frosty -Ccino
Wendy’S All Natural Strawberry and Tropical Berry Lemonades
Sit down
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
"This location has improved substantially in the last month! They have to be under new management. Everyone who works here is super friendly, fast,..."
Leighann D.
"Stopped by today with the last $5 I had to get my kids an "on the go lunch". Truly had HOT fries, HOT burgers, and the BEST spicy chicken go-wrap..."
Kaylee Walker
"Was fast and accurate and friendly. Ordered grilled chicken sandwich and apple pecan salad. We enjoyed..."
"Pizza cottage delivery! I am a low carb eater and want to acknowledge that cauliflower crust isn't super low in carbs. Having said that the..."
Nicci Faw
"The first time we came here we got mushroom pizza and they were canned and tasted awful- but then we came back for a birthday party and got to try..."
John and Lara Y
"I had their signature PLT sub with crispy pepperoni provolone cheese lettuce roma tomatoes and mayonnaise. It was pretty good. Correction. There are..."
John Croyle
"Breadsticks were lack luster. Imagine sub rolls with melted cheese. They were hot, soft and buttery.
Mozzarella sticks gave us life. Triangles...."
Lirea Turner
"We had a large party in the party rooms.
Samantha was our server.
She was fantastic. Service was fast and orders were all correct.
She is very..."
"This is one of my favorite Canes in Columbus! They are always fast, have great service, friendly at the windows and get your order..."
tyann amos
"Taste and service are as good as ever but since COVID, the portion sizes of the chicken are about half the size that they used to be. Before it was..."
Adam Bowen
"So happy to see the dining room open again!! Now I can get those juicy, tender with a crunch chicken fingers so fresh hot to the table that I had to..."
Matt Kamm
"The drive thru line moved super fast! The employees were really nice on the intercom. It tasted delicious and I’ll definitely be back..."
"Fast seating. Server was super sweet. Food tasted and look..."
Brittany Monfils
"My wife and I stopped in after church to get a bite and visit. We got a booth in the corner next to the window. Let me just say that we enjoyed our..."
"Fun, laughter and a great time!
I had my grand daughters birthday party at Rule 3 this past weekend. It was a great experience. The young lady that..."
Shameka Jones
"My sister booked a party yesterday. Staff are super nice. We had the min bowling to our self it just a room with 4 lanes. We order pizza the host..."
darling Mclean
"We celebrated our sons birthday at Rule 3 with mini bowling. They had such a great time. Our host Talia was wonderful. She was very attentive and..."
Wendy Neal
"We celebrate last Friday our son birthday and the kids had so much fun playing bowling. Food, drinks and arcade was great. Our waitress was fenomenal..."
Karin Xander
"Hello,
Our Basketball Banquet held March 5,2022 was an amazing experience. Scott was wonderful to work with. Natalie B was a wonderful host. The..."
Donta' Greene Sr.
"On 03/12/22 I had my granddaughters 2nd b-day here & I will say turned out better then I expected. The mini bowling area was private. Seating was..."
Andrea Johnson
"Was my first time there...Invited to a Birthday party. We had the mini bowling area....it was a blast. Great food, friendly..."
"I’ve been here numerous times and have only had one bad experience. One time they only had one worker and it was slammed. I don’t blame her for..."
T Frazee
"I've always loved Subway! This location can be a little slow sometimes and employees aren't consistent. The friendliness of the staff varies. I'm..."
Antique Shopper
"My family and I ate here last night and we have never been so impressed with a Subway in our entire lives! We had a very rambunctious, hyper 2 year..."
Dee Ann Pereyra-Lopez
"I wandered my way over to Subway the other day to fulfill my dying need of a pizza sub. I know this isn't your standard Subway meal so of course I..."
Sara Lemieux
"Very nice and friendly staff. There's one kid in there with brown curly hair and I see him really taking his job to passion. He had a friendly voice..."
Joey Davisson
"Friendly, concerned about what they do, and make. Have been there a couple of times. They are the closest subway to me, now that a refuse to go to my..."
Wayne Charles
"I've always gotten good service there, despite all the changes in personnel over the years. I was just there today, and there was only ONE person..."
"Always properly salting their fries, so no problems there. Personally I don't eat the burgers from anywhere, my son loves their chicken nuggets and I..."
NaKenzie Manns
"We love going to the Wendy's/Tim Horton's in the Kroger & St Rt 256. The employees are friendly, attentive. Dining area is always clean. Now let's..."
Sharon McKinley
"We ate inside. Very clean! Food was hot and tasty and the service was fast and friendly. I love their pop machine. You can mix up about any..."
Dawn Fines
"A great fast food experience. Friendly staff, competent and fast. I drive out of my way to this Wendy's just to avoid the one on gender near refugee...."
"They were out of fried mushrooms but their onion rings are good and we're a good substitute. I ordered pretzel sticks with cheese but didn't realize..."
Kelli Bailey
"This is the only great ice cream like store in pickerington. No offense to the others. This place has perfect ice cream. Chocolate and vanilla is my..."
"No wonder it’s so famous in the town. I loved the food. Staff is very welcoming. Clean place. Wonderful hibachi experience. Place for big group as..."
Riya Acharya
"Had an awesome experience here for lunch. Great service and excellent food. The hibachi chef didn't show much showmanship with his cooking but the..."
David A.
"Dinner for my wife's birthday. Server was attentive and our chef was quick and personable. All three meals were great and I have lunch for..."
Mark E.
"Took the girlfriend here for Valentines day. Pricy, but DEFINETLY worth it! The chefs are entertaining and the food is..."
Daniel Earl
"My two mothers and I came in for a late birthday dinner a few days ago as we hadn't quite been able to afford it on the day of. We were the first to..."
Alumit Damianos
"I really enjoyed the experience! The chef was funny and interactive with all the guest. Food was delicious and got a lot for what I paid for. The..."
"I always enjoy Old Bag. I had my first visit at the Pickerington location, our waiter very good, pleasant and knowledgeable. Side salad was..."
Kenya Banks
"There was a small wait so I sat at the bar to watch the news until my table was ready. The bartender was the perfect amount of friendly, attentive..."
Kim Hughes
"Nice atmosphere! Their pepper soup is DELICIOUS! Very nice sized portions! Their blackened fish or shrimp is YUMMY! They also have a bar so drinks..."
Diana Otto
"I've always like them and have enjoyed their restaurant for many years. This location is as good as there location in Centerville, Ohio. With a good..."
"This is the best KFC I have had. The store was clean, the staff was awesome and the food was..."
Elon Nichols
"The service was good, the lines was long, but they were moving. My 🐟🐠 was hot &..."
Mz Hollywood (Mzholleewud)
"Food was okay. Seem to be a little drier than usual. Used in drive-through bit confusing when you have two different voices coming over the..."
Howard J
"I've been waiting for this location to open the dining room back up and wasn't disappointed. Food was as I remember growing up and the dining room..."
Dustin Hannahs
"Food was hot hush puppies were fresh. People working there were also..."
ken kooser
"My experience was so good today that I had to write a review. My fried fish was perfectly crispy and piping hot! The lady at the window brightened..."
"I had such a refreshing and pleasant experience here! The kids working were so kind and attentive. The food was excellent and made super fast...."
Nikki Morscher
"I go here for the Vito unwich!!! They use fresh lettuce to wrap the sandwich. I really like it...my favorite is that the sandwich can easily be a..."
Sherri Floyd
"Recognizing these times are hard for shops like Jersey Mikes. Am a frequent customer, and usually find product and service good. Be wary of the 5-7..."
Howard Meiburg
"Good Subs, Hot and Cold. Walk in, Dine in, or carry out. On line ordering possible, but not always companies site (3rd Party delivery..."
"We enjoyed this place. We had the regular size 3-way. It was great. Service was good. I would definitely recommend this..."
Nate B
"Can't beat Skyline's 3-way when you are craving that Cincinnati taste! We always stop in when visiting Cincy and missed it this time since we were..."
B. Morgan
"It's an Ohio thing. Place was roomy and food was good. Wait staff did an amazing job. Yes one of their ingredients in their chili is..."
Adena Gwirtz
"Our group was welcomed in the dining area, tables placed for us to be comfortable. Server was amazing, food prepared as..."
Janet Cahill
"Great customer service and EVERYONE was masked. Food and drink orders taken within a minute of sitting down. Food was fast and hot. Low price for 2..."
Rita White
"This is the largest Skyline I have been in besides Cinci location. Food was good, service was fast and facility was clean. Enjoyed this location and..."
"The food is amazing! Always fresh and delicious! There are lots of different options in the menu. Some of our favorites are the big burrito covered..."
Daniela
"Great Mexican meal, highly recommend. Fantastic chips and salsa (the large for 6.99 is good for 4 people), tacos de barbacoa was excellent. The pick..."
John and Lara Y
"Professional service , and nice people. We did enjoy time being there !!👍🏻
The food is very delicious !!!!!!
I recommend this place..."
Carolina B.
"Got seated immediately! They have chips & salsa for appetizer for free! Always a friendly staff! Nice menu with quite a few different options-..."
Diana Otto
"The manager is so sweet and inviting! Our waitress was wonderful. Our food was delicious! We were treated very well. I really enjoyed the entire..."
Sam S
"Amazing food, and drinks! Service was excellent and the staff was so kind. I went here for my 21st birthday and they made it so special. Would highly..."
"I have been eating at this restaurant for almost 10 years now. I've watched this restaurant grow and expand over the years. It used to be just the..."
Frankie Collins
"This is my go to Sushi place for my wife and I. I have gone here more than 10 times and everytime it is excellent. Staff is nice. Prices are very..."
Merlin89 “Merlin89”
"This is a very good sushi restaurant. Good quality, great service and reasonably priced.
Not sure why I see negative review for service. I felt that..."
Karl Schulman
"Stopped in for lunch. I've been a few times and it's always been..."
Brian Crawford
"Been here several times , the food is always great. Past 2 years we've gotten ot as take out and the food is just as..."
Amber Herbert
"Great service!! The Pickerington Roll was a great Top Pick. I've had bigger appetizer portions at other sushi spots and u might want to switch sauces..."
Anna Powell
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes