The best Restaurants in Pickerington ranking of February 2025
122 restaurant menus in Pickerington, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
"Food is good. If you search a little for coupons or take advantage of the kids eat free dats it is very affordable. My only criticism would be that..."
Spencer
"My grandkids and I had a great dinner at Max & Ermas tonight. The food was mostly excellent. One grandchild had the kids meal pizza which was ok and..."
sprkl sprkl
"Ordered a cup of TORTILLA Soup and KALBI FAJITA TACOS for dinner. the soup was good; the chicken is soft and the taste was..."
Mcken Mak
"Fun, family and sports resturant and bar.
Kids eat free on Tuesday. Large groups welcome. Known for their burgers. Fresh, big and yummy. Small..."
Laura Kaplan
"ABSOLUTELY THE BEST!! Fantastic servers and phenomenal managers!
They went out of their way to make sure our very large orders are perfect every..."
Stacey Holmes
"Went to dinner with my husband and was promptly seated at a booth. Our server quickly approached to get our drink order and tell us about the soup of..."
Cassidy Bailey
"Everything was delicious! They have THE BEST Chicken tortilla soup I have EVER had!!!!! We ordered the special of a burger, side and soup and dessert..."
"I have been wanting a great tasting pizza for a while and no where gave me what I was looking for. MOD pizza was perfect and worth every penny. It..."
Me me optimistic
"The pizza is good, but it's the service that brings me back! The crew I witnessed at the Pickerington location (multiple times) is the most..."
Angela Beatty
"MOD pizza is a great fresh choice for any meal. This visit was no exception. This is the first time I've tried a salad. It was great! You choose..."
kay arnold
"First time, first experience, first taste Great! im not a meat eater and options Great! customer service Great! options Great keep up the Good..."
jeff willing
"Very nice and professional staffs! Phenomenal..."
it'smel
"Nice place. Very clean and the staff was friendly. Lots of options, there's something there for everyone. Fairly busy but the wait for our pizzas was..."
"So I don't usually by fast food much any more but I had a craving this particular evening. My boyfriend and I placed an online order and in that we..."
Hannah Jewell
"The visit was great. Jaalyn was very attentive and polite. She provided good customer service which should be the norm every where, but..."
"Way over the top!!!! Th.... Way over the top!!!!This is by far the best. Mexican In town The best authentic Mexican we..."
Bigrobandjane
"Despite being busy during weekends they are welcoming. Staff is so nice and friendly. These kind of gestures make us keep coming. Good food and good..."
Riya Acharya
"Great food and outstanding service, one of my favorite places to eat. Highly..."
yessi osorio
"My husband and I have visited this restaurant a few times now and the food is always pretty good Mexican food. We've never had an issue with the..."
CoCo
"One of my favorite Mexican Restaurants around town. Always quick to get seated and the service was great. Combo fajitas did not disappoint. Steak..."
Mindy Williamson
"Zapatas never disappoints! They're always quick, delicious, and very fairly priced. It's definitely our favorite Mexican..."
tiffany stiles
"By far our favorite local Mexican restaurant. We compare every other Mexican place to Zapatas.... and Zapatas always wins. Good food, fast service,..."
Jenelle Leppla
"Had a wonderful time at Zapatas for Cinco DE Mayo, the wait was 40 mins was expected the staff was excellent and the food was outstanding!
The vibe..."
"Went there for dinner last evening. Was seated right away and the server was pleasant. Some items were not on the menu or substituted when asked. ..."
Tony Guzman
"So so so good. The cheese tortellini with vegetables and the Shrimp Omezzo are both delicious! Everything else looked great, too, and the service is..."
Leandra Carlyle
"We just recently visited this local place for the first time. Food was great! Staff was super nice and the atmosphere is very inviting. The owner..."
Mrace43
"We visited Omezzo on a recent Saturday night for my father-in-law's 88th birthday and we couldn't have been happier with our experience. We had a..."
Tom Hisek
"If you haven’t been to Omezzo Restaurant and Pizzeria, you need to drop everything and go. This place is amazing. I recommend the chicken..."
Angie B
"Finally... A place better to eat delicious Italian food other than Olive Garden's (inauthentic) food. Bonus, it's local to Pickerington. How much..."
April Osman
"The food was marvelous and the staff was friendly. We had the veal parm, pasta diavolo, fettuccine Alfredo, and shrimp omezzo and everyone agreed "it..."
Lianna Nordwig
"Omezza was in a strip mall. We did not expect such a beautiful restaurant with wonderful food. I would recommend this for a very nice date..."
"Establishment was clean. Really beautiful statue and art. Service was quick. Menu has chinese,korean, and ty options. Food was hot and delicious. No..."
Shawnae Sellers
"Oh man, I'm so happy to have found this place. It's pretty nice inside and I can't wait to do dine in service once it reopens for that. For now, they..."
Kat Ellery
"One of my favorite restaurants in Pickerington. Thai Paradise
#Pho is featured in the..."
Chevonne
"Ok I'm not sure where the disconnect is with the reviews, but I found this place based on searching "best sushi in Pickerington" and they do not..."
Regina Hunter
"I love Thai food, and I have been to many of the local Thai places. This is the one. No seriously, Thai Paradise is the best. Their food is SO..."
Jacobi Kosiarek
"Was finally able to dine in once again, new chef training going well we enjoyed everything, spicy garlic calamari, dumplings, empress chicken,..."
"This was my first time ordering with firehouse and I will definitely be back. Wonderful potato soup and Italian sub! My boyfriend’s Cuban looks..."
may_fizz Zaragoza
"First time ordering from Firehouse subs. Did a online pickup and that was pretty
good. I ordered a large Italian and cheese stake. Only thing that..."
Dialtone seven
"I’ve been going here for awhile now. My most descent visit was today. I first walked in to find it extremely smoky inside.. surprised the alarm..."
T Frazee
"I'm not a big fan of their potato soup, but their subs are AMAZING! I also love the cause they support as well as their..."
Daniela
"I give 4 stars to the very helpful staff but the New York Steamer was a bust. The meat tasted the same, the bread was too hard to my liking BUT I may..."
"I ordered Falafel pita sandwich and gteek fries...it's really good food, ya falafel patti lettlebit simple but white sauce and hummus are very good..."
ankitmodi23
"First time to Greek Star !!! I can’t believe I have missed this spot.. I had the lunch special gyro and the chicken shawarma and feta fries and..."
"Food is very good. Perfect place for someone who loves Thai food. Our server was good. I can only rate the food here, all dishes we ordered were too..."
Riya Acharya
"For the first time experience it was a good one. The spring rolls were sizable and good. The Blue Thai drink kept me feeling good and not over..."
Steve Sims
"This is a great little place to get authentic pho (soup), Thai food and Sushi. Small and quaint. Nice atmosphere. Good service. Friendly attentive..."
Jan C
"Delicious! The sushi was super fresh, and the spicy noodles were amazing! Potstickerz hit the spot! The lychee martini was different and delicious as..."
Regina Hunter
"Melissa was super! Attentive and very helpful with recommendations. Service was quick. Food was..."
Robert Gruver
"Absolutely delicious! Great items from the entrées to the..."
"I have eaten at this chain restaurant several times. I have found that the staff at this location is typically friendly and provides good service...."
Facebook User
"This is one of the most efficiently run restaurants that I have been to since Covid hit. They were very busy. We were seated quickly and our food..."
IKON IKON
"Very clean, family friendly place. The food was fantastic and inexpensive. The staff was friendly and professional, but also very efficient. It was a..."
Candice Watts
"Very clean and professional staff. Kept checking back to make sure everything was ok. Quick service and they were busy. Very large assortment to..."
Don Wallick
"No line. Sat very quickly. Service was friendly and..."
Joelene Lowe
"Wonderful, kind staff. I’ve ordered to-go here twice and was very pleased. Prices are excellent. Sausage links are delicious! Stuffed French toast..."
Antique Shopper
"Dine in or Carry out, Online ordering possible. Food is great and usually ready for pickup by the time I get there. Very Busy on..."
Howard J
"Excellent service, delicious filling food and great prices! Love this place! This was my first time at this location and we picked a great time to..."
"Love the staff here — stopped going to the one by my house on Brice rd and drive the extra few minutes for better customer service and food! always..."
jade burke
"Was pretty good, a few burritos were missing some ingredients and they didn't give us any sauce after asking for some. Otherwise it was..."
Ashley Perry
"Love this location. Always great service and wonderful staff. My favorite is the Taco Supreme with Sour Cream on the..."
"I'm from NJ and I grew up with mom and pop Italian restaurants. I am not a big fan of Dominos pizza, Pizza Hut, and all these pizza chains. I love..."
Mio Núñez
"This was our first time here and we were VERY impressed. This shop came highly recommended. We chose this location because of the dine in. Ordered a..."
S Y
"We have been ordering their pizza about once every two weeks since November. It always arrives hot and fresh. The wait time is a little longer, but..."
Vanthe
"Pizza is so delicious, crust is so thin, but also not soggy and the sauce to cheese ratio is perfection, so..."
NaKenzie Manns
"This place has the best pizza! I love their style of pizza, the pepperoni pinwheels and their cannolis.
I'd give them 5 stars, but the cook on my..."
Robert Kline
"LOVE this pizza. If you like thin "foldable" crust, this is the place to..."
"Only four stars because we did have to wait kind of long for our mobile order and they had run out of chips. The woman at the pickup window provided..."
Lori Varn
"Out of dressing and didn’t add extra cheese or corn. Still good. For awhile I avoided this location because it was so bad. Good to see it turn..."
"The Patio at Cardo's Pizza is the place to be this summer!! I just attended the Grand Opening, where they launched their new PourMyBeer self-serve..."
Haley Yatzus
"We showed up with an unexpected party of 18 at lunch.
They made sure we had room to all be in the same vicinity and promptly took drink orders.
Food..."
Karla Smith
"We celebrated our sons birthday here. Plenty of room for my family and a few of our closest friends. We all had a great time. The food snd service..."
Scott Donnerberg
"Great subs with awesome chips, it would be cool if you could order extra chips. pizza is great also, love the sausage.
Friendly staff, thanks for..."
P A
"Nice location ! Great customer service! They have a Large outdoor patio also! Patio opening in MAY! Had Lost Coast Beer - very tasty w little bit of..."
Diana Otto
"My first visit last weekend and I was quite pleased! Food was great but the service was even better! Allyson was very attentive and incredibly nice...."
"Quick and easy hibachi without the show and high prices. I’m a huge fan of the yum yum..."
Tara
"Chad is the best employee at this location! He was very helpful during our first time here in explaining the ordering process. He doesn’t fail to..."
Antique Shopper
"First time here, I ordered the steak and shrimp hibachi bowl with fried rice. THE best I have ever had! Food was fresh, and the wait was not long...."
Amyia_ Marie
"What can I say.. it’s take out hibachi!! Yum yum sauce! Clean place and nice people.. also food is..."
Jason Kirk
"Mommy and I went to Genjigo recently and it was very, very good! I got steamed rice, double chicken and double steak. I added some Yum Yum sauce and..."
Michael Glaze Jr.
"When I stopped in, the place was packed with maybe 20 or so people waiting for their food. It took a while to receive it, but the food was delicious!..."
"Very delicious icecream the only downfall was the extremely long wait. Make sure you're not in a hurry when you visit because their is a wait. But..."
Dustin McClain
"Love love love their ice cream!! I always get the same thing.. peanut butter cup perfection, but I substitute the chocolate ice cream for sweet..."
Antique Shopper
"Love that they finally offer dairy free ice cream! Can't wait until they expand the dairy free ice cream..."
Jesse Jolliff
"This is my favorite Cold Stone location. It has a wide selection of chocolates from truffles, to big peanut, almond, and cashew clusters. Peanut..."
Jennifer Bourne
"Wish they offered more dairy free options other than only the pink lemonade sorbet, however the staff were more than willing to check ingredients of..."
Isabella Smith
"Fresh mixed in front of you. Cheap prices. For what you pay for 2 large blizzards at dairy queen, you can get the cone below and another of whatever..."
"They are great for all different types of picky eaters. This place offers amazing Korean food and their kimchi is amazing!!! They also offer..."
Kimberly R
"Great all-American/Korean mix!! Excellent service, wonderful Korean comfort food at VERY reasonable..."
Valerie W.
"We've been here twice now, EXCELLENT food. Great selection of breakfast, American favorites and Korean foods. We've all tried a little of each and..."
Megan Noel
"They say that A &J has been here for 8 years. Wow! For that longtime, this was our first time walking in it. They serves American dishes and Korean..."
Henry Yan
"I had the bibimbap and kimchi jige. Bulgogi was excellent and I like that they included the panchan for to-go. Usually you only get that dining in...."
John and Lara Y
"One of my favorite places to go! I love the stone..."
Travis Van Ness
"We don't usually go to this side of town, but finding this place was a nice surprise. With the name, you're expecting burgers and wings, but this..."
"I like their "grab n go" with social distancing. You have to order online/app or call in. I love the Greek Yogurt Pineapple Mango Smoothie. I also..."
Tiffany Murphy
"First time visiting this location. I had the Greek Yogurt Pineapple Mango, it was REALLY GOOD! However, my time ordering and waiting for the drink..."
Antonia Traylor
"I get two 40oz protien smoothies. Drink half of one and put the rest in freezer to have over the next few days. Going to try making them myself but..."
Joyce Escobar
"Ok what!? Not only does Smoothie King want to help you stay healthy, they're helping keep the Earth healthy!! So happy to be using these straws!!..."
Theresa Garee
"They where about to close and my son split is smoothie cChloe had no problem making a new one for him and was super sweet about it, Jeff also jumped..."
"Really enjoyable pizza. Sweet tomato sauce, similar to Papa John's but even better. Minus one star because there doesn't seem to be a happy medium..."
John and Lara Y
"Worth it to go inside if you do carry out! Gluten free pizza is good and has never caused me to have a reaction unlike several other chains GF pizza...."
"I am a type 2 diabetic and I entered your store to get food. I Had not ate anything all day and I knee my sugar was getting low. As I was ordering I..."
James Stanley
"Nice Jimmy John's. Good stop over driving through Ohio. Friendly..."
Hugh Shoff
"It was really good. You guys might need a little more toppings though. Maybe banana peppers instead of hot peppers and some regular black pepper to..."
"The pizza is really good!! We had the Hawaiian pizza, and a half pepperoni and half cheese pizza, and wings and chicken tenders. Everything was..."
Terrence Johnston
"Great little Pizza Pub. Pizza is really good, with quality ingredients and the perfect sauce. Subs are excellent as well, as is the cheesy bread..."
David Camp
"Best Pizza meat lovers and Mexican. what a surprise Long Island and Marg amazing! Customer service on point ! See ya soon! Psss entertainment book..."
"First trip back since pandemic, we ate inside. Got our usual, pan dbl pep, dbl cheese and bread sticks. Bread sticks and pizza were hot and fresh,..."
"Great customer service and love that they have a drive thru. The ice cream always tastes..."
Kaylie Eisel
"Took the drive thru last couple times and usually got what I wanted within 5-10..."
what if hypothetically i
"Always good..especially for my BIRTHDAY BOY..."
M.K. Chrisss
"The staff seemed very nice when I went. The mango ice cream was delightful. Also love the vienna coffee ice cream! my dog loves the doggy ice cream..."
Zoe Lang
"My favorite ice cream chain since my first childhood taste. Fresh, creamy, creative and definitely worth. Quality off the chain! Always friendly..."
"Oh so good! The staff was friendly. The ice cream is fantastic! So many unique flavors to choose from along with the classics. Plus a large, clean..."
Jen Lake
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes