"Best lunch ever! I arrived at 12 Noon on a weekday just as they were opening. By 12:03pm there were a dozen people in line. THE Most delicious..."
Greg Heelan
"I was told about this place while still living in the UK so, of course, I had to try it. This was the first chance Iāve had since moving back to..."
Denise Dowden
"Picked up some pies for lunch on our way through Richmond, but thought they were so delicious we had to turn around and get more for the road so we..."
John Alexander
"A lot of pie options from sweet to savory. We got iced coffee, strawberry rhubarb, and Buttermilk raspberry. Pie was good and coffee was good with..."
Rashaad Kauterman
"Salmon, leek, and potato pie was divine! And the key lime pie is by far the best one that I have ever tried! Friendly service and freshly handmade..."
Doug Donaldson
"Yum yum yum! I'm usually not huge on bread-y foods, but Proper Pie ended up being a ray of sunshine. I enjoyed their smoked salmon, leek, and potato..."
Ally Capwn
"These pies are amazing! They have a good selection of savory and sweet. When I went we got the spinach feta chickpea and the smoked salmon potato..."
Muniba Khan
"Very tasty stuff here. Easy order from the hole. Mango ginger pie has a delightful subtle taste with chunks if..."
A. Green
"I found out about Proper Pie only a week before Thanksgiving. Nevertheless, once I saw the Salted Caramel Pumpkin Pie on their fall menu, I made it..."
Dena Cooper
"Iām not really much of a pie person but this place my goodness is really really delicious! We ordered the Banana Cream, Dutch Apple, Blueberry..."
Vsa K
"We headed to proper pie because we love pie. It helped to have a local here - take orders online starting at 10 then you pick it up. Steak and..."
David Brenton
"The Ham and Swiss savory pie is quite possibly the best thing I've ever eaten. The service was amazing..efficient order fulfillment, friendly and..."
Dawn Mabry
"Awesome place with some delicious pies! Yet to have a dessert pie since I'm not to bad at making the baked treats my own self, but have definitely..."
TheLeakingGenius
"Great food! Steak and Guinness pie was outstanding! The strawberry rhubarb pie fell a bit flat. I kind of expected a bit more. Personal preference..."
Paul Brookes
"Always the best temperature, taste, and crust of any pies you can buy. Plus theyāre affordable and unique. The apple pulled pork is probably my..."
Kieran Morley
"One of my top favorite places for key lime pie. You gotta go try it out! Itās worth it. You order outside but they are super fast and..."
Jason Nicholas
"I took friends because it was close enough to drive from the court house. I went the year they opened. It's been there 20 years. It's even better..."
Mary Donahue
"Google maps is off by a block. Just past historic St John's Church on the same side of the street. Short and wonderfully eclectic menu of savory and..."
TG Fitch (VA Renaissance Man)
"Amazing pie. The quality here has not been matched by anyone else that Iāve seen.
Note, though, that since Covid, they are take-out only, and have..."
Parvez Khan
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes