Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Staten Island
134 restaurant menus in Staten Island, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
"Let me start by saying, the owner Mike is absolutely wonderful, respectful, old school, too many good things to be said. Even his staff is super..."
Jackie R.
"What an awesome place! The food here is just amazing. You've never had fresh mozzarella like they have, I promise you. The prosciutto bread is to die..."
Michael Petrik
"I've had a lot of mozzarella in my life and this place has the BEST fresh mozzarella by far. Words don't do it any justice. Try it, you'll lose your..."
N
"From the minute that you walk in your sense of smell will be transported to heaven. Excellent food, the best customer service, we felt so welcomed!..."
Kim Brennan
"I think the word Famiglia is very telling. When you go here you feel like family. It does have the absolute best fresh mozzarella cheese ever made...."
Joseph Caffrey
"Amazing staff amazing sandwiches..really impressed an it was great to enter a nice old school place. Honestly I got two sandwiches and they were huge..."
Andrew Ley
"Sweet Stuffed Peppers Try them you think you died and went to HEAVEN. Prosciutto bread no words can describe the..."
TONY “TONY” GIGLIA
"The nicest family. The first time I went there Mike had me feeling like I was one of his family. The food was excellent. I loveeeeeeeeeeee his..."
"This place has outstanding pizza with a wide variety of specialty types. We had a sampling of the slices and we recommend the Big Boy Mac pizza,..."
Suzanne Alexandra Ascher
"Delicious Pizza. We really like the taste and the size was huge. Definitely if we come back for vacations we won't miss to visit this..."
Haydee Romani Ramos
"Have to say, I had not had anything from here I didn't like. Vodka sauce is delicious, pizza's are great and food is delicious! Way to go..."
CarlaAnn Volpe
"Calamari squared was amazing! Ordered for the first time tonight and I think we've found our new pizza..."
Maria Vicinanza
"I'm there 1-2 times a week food is great � never had anything that I didn't..."
Anthony Colon
"Amazing service, food was a hit straight out the park, new guys in town, they have a bright future ahead of them. Keep it up guys! Will definitely be..."
Novenia Sohail
"The people are so super nice, especially the cashier girl with dark hair. The even customized a weird order for my keto diet. The food is AWESOME..."
Deena Ann
"This pizza place was awesome!!! We passed by before heading to the beach and this pizza place came up the closest. The staff were nice and the foods..."
Rm Diwa
"Best pizza on Staten Island. No joke. It’s so embarrassing of me for not visiting this joint sooner. Amazing customer experience and most..."
The Cryptotainer
"This pizza shop is so good. They have different varieties of pizza and everything tastes so fresh. I've eaten a little bit of everything off of the..."
J Gee
"This place is amazing the food is incredible the people make you feel like family and the prices are almost unreal if you have not tried it please..."
"Went out to dinner with my family to Sofra Bar & Grill in Staten Island, NY and had a great experience. Staff were very friendly and accommodating to..."
Edona Kelmendi
"I love this place. My family came in from Florida and we have been going there regularly. The food is excellent, bartender is very nice and drinks..."
Franca Costa
"I love this place, it's amazing. The food is fantastic and the service is..."
Zeacorzeppelin10
"Warm and friendly place!
The food was excellent I had the meatball sliders delicious everything was wonderful
Make a trip..."
"The coffee is very fresh! I liked it more than your local dunkin donuts or starbucks The staff was..."
Martin Allen
"Enjoy the service the food was very good with large portions .the atmosphere of the place was warm and inviting. Very clean and nicely decorated. I..."
Nancy Ashon Poku
"Place is great, good coffee and food. Pool room is awesome. Definitely the place to..."
Jason Davis Davis
"Nice little restaurant and the customer service was excellent the food was very..."
Ray Perez
"Super delicious food at very low price. Very friendly..."
Young fine artists Academy
"Great customer service and a great decoration! Great place to shoot some..."
Jimmy Nvrz
"Great vibes, good coffee. Nice outdoor..."
A Abel-Bey
"Lovely place and great owners who really try to contribute to the neighborhood and..."
"Wow. What an amazing dining experience. So small and intimate - a one of kind experience. Love tapas - and so much of the food here is delicious...."
Erin Sarnes
"This place is fantastic. Unlike anything else on the island. The food (we had beet salad, beef carpaccio, tiramisu, and pannacotta) is quality,..."
Heather Tolan
"Eating an awesome meal at my favorite restaurant and guess who i spot across the dining room...Elvis Duran from Z100’s morning show. This place is..."
PJ Bergin
"Massimo and staff exceeded our expectations .
The food was amazing and finally, a new go to place on Staten..."
Peter Kanakos
"Never disappointed with this fabulous restaurant! The food is amazing,and as soon as you walk inside you think you’re eating in a quaint little..."
Lillian Palumbo
"Great addition to the North Shore. Enjoyed the small plates and wine. Massimo and his staff were warm and welcomed everyone in to a beautiful..."
Eileen Sullivan Christie
"Everything was perfection! Subtle and flavorful food, with so much choice, we HAVE to go back! Beautiful wine and exceptional..."
Janet Savage
"Loved it! Enjoyed a fabulous lunch and service and owner were hands on! Can’t wait to go back..."
Kathloon Kelly
"Some of the most authentic italian cooking Ive had in a very long time. Make the trip to staten Island, its so worth it. The lamb meatballs will..."
"Amazing pizza that doesn't penny pinch for quality. Everyone in the pizzeria is friendly and treat you like family. Even if you havent been in the..."
Joe Catz
"Neighborhood pizza place we regret not trying sooner. We have tried many different things and everything has been so good. Exception was fried..."
Michael G
"Pizza is very tasty. Sausage and broccoli rabe is prepared perfectly and the hero sandwiches are well stuffed. My go-to place when we don't feel like..."
Frank Castellano
"White Slice was very good!! Regular slice better then alot of places I've..."
Joe Frascati
"This pizza is delicious . The owner is a really stand up individual ! Courteous and..."
Brandon
"Chicken rolls with vodka sauce is great. I ordered one chicken and one sausage and pepper roll but they gave me two chicken instead. Wasn’t..."
"I had always driven by there. Tonight i stopped and had an amazing dinner.
The finest Italian food in Staten Island, i think if you ask any New..."
Frank Aloshi
"For some of my friends it was their time I was There once before. Very good service , food was excellent everything came out hot , Lou our waiter was..."
Raymond Casamento
"Just performed there at a party, and have been to enough establishments to know the difference. Excellent food and the staff is first rate! Clean,..."
Russ Paladino
"First time at Nino's. Went on Easter Sunday. I hate to eat in restaurants on holidays however Nino's has changed my mind. Excellent food on a very..."
Gerard M. Murphy
"My family,friends , friends of friends love this place! The food here is phenomenal the people are so sweet the setting is lovely I've been coming..."
Raven Traina
"“Italian Food with Bold Satisfying Flavor!”
Went to dinner with my wife. We both ordered from the three course menu. Began with the Eggplant..."
Charles DeVito
"This place is simply amazing, from the excellent food to the best staff. Always making you feel like family. We go there twice a week and my family..."
Agron Hajdari
"My wife and two daughters FINALLY made it in yesterday. We have lived on Staten Island for 21 years and tried coming here once before but the wait..."
Yarvis Torres
"This is one of my favorite places to eat The food is awesome the waiters are great the owner Agim is fantastic Can't wait to go back everyone..."
James M Rodgers
"The food is always great!
Service top notch ...
The atmosphere is light and relaxing
I personally have had parties in their party room and you get..."
Gina Russo
"Great food, great service! We had my mother's 75th birthday party there and it was simply amazing. The professionalism of the entire crew was on..."
Lisa Quinn
"Went to dinner with my family and it was awesome. The food was delicious from the appetizers to the dessert. The atmosphere was very nice too. The..."
Giovanna Gigi Guarneri
"Highly recommend love the service and the food everything delicious, love the quality of the menus and the food definitely one of my favorite places..."
Fatima Mejia
"P.S. 52 had their end term/retirement party there last night and everything was perfect. From the valet parking, right to the last drop of coffee -..."
"Great NYC style Sicilian pie.
Bright, clean sauce. A little on the wet side. Crust was plain. Slices are limp, need both hands. Have some napkins..."
Pete Breza
"We are moving to Florida and wanted to get some good NY pizza before we go and my boyfriend found this place he grabbed a quick slice and came home..."
Nancy Fasolino
"Tiny, but amazing pizzeria/restaurant. Our first time eating here and Justine’s service was phenomenal. She was very polite, professional and..."
Ye Aung
"Excellent Pizza. We have ordered a bunch of times and just the other day we ordered the family special. Great deal, the definitely don't skimp and..."
Michael G
"We went to a Communion party there and the atmosphere was great, staff was on top of everything and the FOOD WAS AMAZING! Delicious food and great..."
Lisa Ratner
"I placed an order last week at your Annandale location with Taylor Smith and she was FANTASTIC!!! she took her time, repeated the order back to me..."
"The workers were so friendly from the get go no sour pusses here,food was amazing,the owner came over with shots on the house and a nutella pie that..."
Mary Jo Reynolds Penkower
"My first time here was for lunch with my best friend and her son. The food was amazing, the freshness and quality was excellent and so delicious! ..."
Danielle Bartow-Demarest
"I threw my daughters graduation party here yesterday. A little pricey, but well worth it. The food was delicious, the service was outstanding. We..."
Karen Anne
"The place is a gold mine!!! We had reservations on a Saturday night and still had to wait about 40 minutes for a table! That has to tell you..."
Tonya Lisa Reyes
"This is one of the best restaurants I’ve ever been to...the food is second to none and the staff are extremely courteous and friendly. We were a..."
Brad Kubis
"My family and I absolutely love Patrizia's! The food is outrageous the atmosphere is outrageous , the staff is professional and courteous! Giacomo..."
John Brullo
"It’s a mini Italian vacation. Every waiter is from Italy. Every waiter speaks Italian. They are too happy to share Italy with you. Love..."
Susan Conlon
"Always an excellent experience! The service was great our waiter was very attentive and we wanted for nothing!! food was delicious..can’t wait to..."
Julie Kraftsman
"Very friendly staff, you can’t beat the food and of course his delicious..."
"This is the best pizzeria in new york city forget just staten island. The best service, the best prices, and the best taste! Just because they dont..."
Steven Thomas
"My family & I have been going to classic for as long as I can..."
Alex Mahoney
"By far my favorite pizzeria on Staten Island!!! The kitchen is awesome as..."
Very Berry Naked Cake with Chocolate Covered Strawberries
Italian
Breakfast
Dinner
Lunch
"My favorite bakery in the Island!!! Their red velvet cake is the best I ever tasted. I am yet to try anything from this bakery that it doesn't taste..."
Steffania Zhingre
"If you need a cake that tastes exceptional and made on time this is the place to go, I showed them a description of the cake I wanted in such a short..."
Itz Lummy
"My favorite bakery on Staten Island. Apple Horseshoe, lemon drop cookies and raspberry brownie bites are must to try. But they really outdone..."
Mariya Grishin
"I bought the pear custard pie, oh my gosh it’s DELICIOUS ❤️ my family loves this pie so much. The best I ever taste!!!!! I’m ordering more...."
Tee Diamond
"I ordered my son’s first birthday cake over the phone and email. Jessica was very friendly and helpful, she helped me decide on the flavors too as..."
Maira Naim
"ordered a cake for a gender reveal,was beautiful and delicious.I would order more cakes for special occasions.Their customer service was professional..."
Luis Ortiz
"My first time coming to this place. I love it. I came with the owner James and he gave me a free cake. Thanks so much James. I'll try it when I get..."
Mike Kong
"Less calorie and less sugar.
Best bakery in NY.
And so kind like belows.
I asked to write down Korean.
So..."
"I have not been to this restaurant in years I went to a party probably about five years ago and thought it was very good but for some reason I never..."
Kathy Vairo
"I come to this restaurant a lot. I've had birthdays, anniversaries, confirmation and communion at this place. We also ate there for thanksgiving! I..."
Concetta Spinella
"We went to this restaurant for the first time... Food is amazing, the staff is great.. Big selection on the menu.. You do not leave this..."
Maria Spanzi
"This restaurant never disappoints. Italian food done very well, with an extensive menu. Weekends include lovely entertainment; weekdays their prix..."
Analia Ricciardo Gerard
"I been here a few times already & again last night. Never been disappointed with the food or the service. Their menu is great & always have a nice..."
Amy Lynn
"The staff were very attentive, the service on point and the food was great! I am definitely going to..."
Kimberly Chesner
"We have eaten here numerous times. The food is delicious and the service is wonderful. Besides the menu they offer specials of the day. What ever you..."
Maria D'Agati Santarpia
"Tucked in a corner of
A little shopping center this is a real hidden gem.
The food and nightly specials were exceptionally tasty and well..."
Mitchell Fuchs
"My family has been going there since they first opened their doors and we have never had a bad or even average meal there! Always fresh, always..."
Maria Tedesco Ditta
"The food is the best on Staten Island !!! The service is wonderful and pleasant , they treat you like family with individual care � I love this..."
Lisa Asenata
"All courses, just delicious.
Pleasant staff.
And the expresso martini was quite tasty!
They also have an all inclusive dinner special during the..."
Julie Baylor-Klimowicz
"My first visit to this delicious restaurant was for a family dinner last night in celebration of my mother-in-laws birthday. Each course from..."
Deborah Cusumano-Fortune
"It was our first time there and the 5 of us enjoyed all our meals! All the extras that they include with your meal was a great touch. The fried..."
Judy Brown-Ginsburg
"Hadn't been to Piccolino in a long time. Everything was delicious. Portions were great and staff couldn't have been more attentive. The musicians..."
"We catered food for our sons birthday. Everything was amazing! We ordered Chicken Marsala, Linguini w/ White Clam Sauce, Penne Vodka, Sautéed..."
Jessica DePetro
"Food was really good! And huge huge servings! ❤️ you can even share!
Waiter is very hospitable.. enjoying Italian music while eating!..."
Jane Wood
"Real New York style Italian pizza. Big chunks of real sausage, real pepperoni and anchovies. So many fakes out there, it was great to finally have..."
Patrick Flanagan
"Excellent food! Everything we ordered was freshly made and delicious. The place is spotless, cozy and quiet just enough to carry on a..."
Sal Cartiglia
"I went to dinner with friends and my fiancee..they love this place. I thought it was just ok...I had the stuffed artichoke which was cooked..."
Janet Manganiello
"The food is amazing and service is one of a kind. I strongly recommend trying this place out when you have a chance. They have an excellent menu..."
Marlon Valdez
"The food is consistently excellent. They have the best pasta e fagioli on the island. Some of our other favorites include the mozzarella carrozza,..."
Jamie Lynn Kiernan
"I love it... it's better than other restaurants around here... food is delicious, prices are fair and service is top..."
"The food here is amazing. You can never go wrong with anything at Village..."
Joby Kuriakose
"The best in Staten..."
VinjoSarah Dela Rosa
"Pizza one of the best in IS & Great Authentic Italian Food! I recommend this..."
Joe Ayala
"This people making delicious pizza. So many verities. I did oder half chicken and half calamari pie.It was delicious. Place is very clean. Very good..."
yakkhanadha
"Pretty good pizza, well priced, great window variety for specialty slices, a regular..."
IG_at onetwojongo
"The food is quality everything I have ordered from them is better then most restaurants. Once in a while it might not be what expected but..."
Jo Ann Silva
"I’m always searching for a new pizza place for delivery. Usually, the particular specials of a place, plus recommendations from friends, will draw..."
Jonathan Rossi
"Amazing food, customer service, and was very clean. This was my first time ordering, but definitely not my..."
Benjamin Kazani
"Nice friendly neighborhood pizzeria!! A superb Sicilian slice at this joint. I have yet to try another other of their offerings but that's only..."
"AMAZING. The food was great and very reasonably priced. It was a very nice atmosphere and the employees made me feel like i was at home. I had Roland..."
Stacy
"Mangia!. What a meal! My favorite dish is the Chicken Eugene which Dom was taught by his Uncle. "Gene's" who was famous on SI for his restaurant too...."
Twotimer2x
"Girls Night Out!. The last time I had dinner with this level of Superior Food and Great Atmosphere I was at my Grandmother's house in Redhook many..."
Debbie
"In one word, EXCELLENT!!!!!. My husband & I have eaten here several times... Never' ever are we disappointed! The portions are huge, the food is..."
Donna
"Well kept SI secret... shhh. Authentic family-style Italian, good, manageable portions, and, more importantly, good tasting! Always go home with a..."
Michael Duffy
"Casa nova. The best place on staten island the food is great the owner dominick is a great chef and good singer too. don't miss this..."
Stevie Cigars
"The food was good, nothing was great or memorable. We took home three slices of bar pie, two thirds of the bread basket (too good to waste), half of..."
"It was my first time there
The food was great the owner Janet was awesome and a gracious host
I definitely will be going back
I would..."
Aggie Salas
"You are always guaranteed a fabulous time at Giuliani's! The food is excellent, the staff are the best and the best part is the owner Janet, who will..."
Lisa Carballeira Modica
"I have been to Giuliana's on a few occasions and I have to say Delicious food & great service Every time ! Loved it !! Would definitely be back and..."
Michele DeMeo
"Janet your place brings me back to the neighborhood. Love seeing all the old friends. The band The Chilo's was great & the dinner & service was..."
Camille Caliano
"Best place to eat great food great atmosphere and great service highly recommend this..."
Marissa Amerose
"Can’t say enough great things about Giuliana’s. The food, the atmosphere and the staff are WONDERFUL. I’ve hosted several dinner parties here..."
Claudine Paradiso
"Enjoyed a great dinner at Giuliana's! Everything I ate was incredibally prepared, from the fried calamari to the chicken francese! The impeccable..."
Carmel Gallo Termotto
"The food is always great and the staff is friendly and attentive. They have wonderful music on saturday's. But the best part is Janet. She always..."
John Fortunato
"Excellent food Excellent SERVICE my Family also enjoyed it as well.Been there multiple times and the food is just delicious, Can wait to go back..."
Jay Spatarella
"Food was Excellent, Great Hospitality and they play the best..."
Guido San
"The best, can't beat the food and the service always..."
Patricia Piccirillo Esposito
"Loved it!!! From the waiter, the food and the Sangria was absolutely amazing! Had the grilled octopus and chicken franchese! All delicious! ..."
"Awesome pizza!!! I used to get my pizza in Brooklyn, then we found Krispy Pizza - my girls won't eat anything else!!! Very nice owners and very..."
Dora Live Laugh Love
"Best pizza on Staten Island!! Excellent service!! Try the wraps and dinner specials!! The place is spotless and they even have outdoor..."
Gianvito Re
"Best Pizzeria In Staten Island , Thank you Brooklyn for setting up shop on the island.Ive been eating at Krispys for 27 years and could'nt be..."
Kurt Dunlap
"BUONISSIMA :) :p COMPLIMENTI :) A PRESTO NON VEDO L'ORA AMICO MIO :) TI RACCOMANDO IL CAFFE..."
Sonia Spiritolibero Vella
"Review update- from 3 star to 5. Food is delicious and every delivery has been on time. I’m happy they are doing..."
Omar Khan
"This is a good pizza. Small size but good amount of cheese and sauce for the money ($2.50). Good taste. Good crust composition as far as chewy /..."
Gary Wilson
"Great pizza! Crispy crust, thin slices, yummy and delicious. Very fresh. We are from Brooklyn and are hard to please when it comes to pizza. We love..."
Irene Limongelli-Rosiello
"John the owner is the real deal! had eggplant parm and it was the only eggplant parm that was made correctly, mariannas is the ONLY pizza place i..."
Halfbakedd69
"some of the very best pizza on staten island. i laugh at some of these reviews. i have been going there for years the new ownership is friendly..."
Anderson Greylock
"Stopped in to let my 6yr old use the bathroom and grab a quick order of garlic knots. Didn’t realize the credit card minimum was $10 and had no..."
Mike C
"Ordered via Uber eats and didn’t know what to expect but WOW the chicken parm and eggplant parm heros we ordered were soooo goood !!! Bread was..."
Kaitlin Martinez
Connect with Sluurpy
X
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes