Italian cuisine: the best places to taste it in Staten Island
134 restaurant menus in Staten Island, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated)
Selected filters:
"Awesome food! Meatballs and pizza are the best I have ever had. Great atmosphere and top notch wait staff. Highly recommend you visit..."
Justin Rivera
"We had such Amazing food and Excellent service at Millie's..Diana our server and everyone else made the dining experience superior! Very authentic..."
Lisa Carvano
"We tried the meatball parm pizza and the vodka pie, both were fantastic. Service was great. Will definitely go..."
Franca Wilson
"Been here multiple times already. Everything about this place is great. Food, service and..."
Michael Pavone
"I love Millie’s!!! Everything is so delicious... especially the vodka meatballs and mashed potato pie😍😍 Can’t wait to go..."
Candice Parlante
"Amazing food, excellent service and fun atmosphere. We’ve been there twice in two..."
Sandra Verity
"Food was delish. Service was..."
Cindy Jo
"Great meatballs & Great pies..."
Michael Major
"WOW, JUST WHAT THE ISLAND..."
Nicholas Racioppo
"Millie's is an absolutely incredible restaurant on so many levels. In fact, from my experience - it is more than a restaurant. It is a dining..."
123 Publish Incorporated
"Excellent Highly recommend. We had 3 of the coal fired pizzas. It was light and crispy, crust was delicious. So good definitely going back..."
Michael G
"Our waitress was very pleasant and the food was delicious! As an Italian Woman I was able to really appreciate the authentic flavor of the vodka..."
Marisa Streppone
"A group of us went on a Sunday, they were running a special $20 all you can eat. We definitely took them on their offer and arrived with an empty..."
Robert Nelson
"I can't believe I never commented about Millie's before. I've eaten here so many times. The food and service and can't be beat. Amir the manager is a..."
Cindy Aliseo
"Went to Millie’s of Staten Island it was amazing got the meatball coal pizza. The owner Brandon came over to see how we liked it and of course told..."
Nicholas Bianchi
"We have been to the Morristown location many times. When we were looking for a place to eat in Staten Island we saw a Millies and could resist..."
Susan Prisco Realtor
"Excellent house red. Pizza is made fresh from scratch- not greasy at all. The meatballs lived up to their reputation- absolutely AMAZING. Antipasto..."
"My brother always orders here and I was in town and decided to try. First impression was very quiet, clean, and welcoming. Very nice breeze with door..."
Elizabeth A
"A small but very personable restaurant. The vodka penne pizza is fantastic. Prices are even a little bit cheaper than other locations. Parking is..."
James Hanrahan
"Excellent pizza. Always crispy and not overloaded with cheese. Dough never too salty. My new pizza spot! Bye bye..."
Bianca R
"A must have pizza very..."
Ceaz G
"I have been going there for years. Everything they make is really..."
adele randazzo
"Pizza is super delicious and the people that work there are super nice. Would highly recommend this place if you are in the..."
Elizabeth K
"Great pizza and amazing..."
Lasal
"Love the food. The owners are warm and friendly. The food is good, my favorite is the carini hero. Excellent rice balls. The pizza is good too! They..."
"Just here yesterday for birthday celebration We go here often great restaurant if u are looking for good food this is the place nice casual..."
Teresa Russo Trovello
"Great staff, delicious food. Don't know WTF people are complaining about. The only thing I would tell them is lower the music a bit. The music itself..."
April Lynn
"Best calamari and pizza i had in a long time. Anthony our server was top notch! Will be going again very..."
Randy Gigante-Zimmerman
"It is absolutely fantastic!! From food to beverages, the service and if course my favorite bar tender Brian !! My favorite place for my hubby and I..."
Michele Petrassi Nasca
"The food was delicious. Everything was fresh. Friendly atmosphere. We missed out on the stuffed zucchini flowers because it was all sold out. That..."
JoAnn Calvo Cassese
"Excellent food and the staff and management are wonderful. My favorite pizzas are the Americano, vodka pie, and Funghi with smoked mozzarella. Be..."
John Camp
"Scrumptious food....pizza awesome...also loved the grilled chicken..."
Michael O'Rourke
"Great night and delicious food and great drinks love it their! The service was wonderful too! A must return although not my first time went to all..."
Lisa Scudera Trombetta
"Delicious from appetizers to sandwiches and pizza best on the..."
Loretta Sarnataro Falco
"My husband threw me a small bday surprise here. Service was OUTSTANDING! Food was delicious! Comfortable atmosphere. Would definitely recommend this..."
"I love to eat and I enjoy a good slice of pizza. And one of the best places to go on Staten Island is this place ,the pizza is crispy it's the..."
Frank Giasi
"This is a small Italian restaurant that was a bit out of our way but their pizza was probably one of the best I ever ate and staff couldn't be any ..."
George Sliwa
"We are from out of town and stayed at the Hilton Garden Inn, by luck ordered delivery pizza & garlic knots and they were fantastic , fast delivery..."
Heather Pangborn
"The best vodka pie on the island
There is no..."
John DiScala
"The best pizza and food in the whole Island, I really recommend it if you ever want to stop by and eat or take out your all welcome. It's awesome try..."
Max Desan
"On a recent visit to Staten Island from Upstate NY, we enjoyed one of the best takeout pizzas ever! Generous fresh toppings, declicious sauce &..."
Thomas Acquisto
"The only place on the island I get pizza from now. The mushrooms alone are worth the..."
James C Hamilton
"If you are looking for some great food served by a very friendly staff, this is your..."
Gina Bunch Russo
"The Pizza and Crew ... DA-Bomb!!
Simply Deeeeeelishhhhhh!!! A must try .. You won't be disappointed . 5..."
Darla Darla
"The best Sicilian squares in New York ! Family owned and operated Check it..."
"Thank you for helping to promote our event and Supporting our Veterans.
The Brothers and Sisters of Rolling Thunder 2..."
Nicole Sforza Chati
"Excellent food and great owners very nice..."
Brian Johnstone
"Always stop when I'm in SI. One of my favorite..."
Jason Sampogna
"Great staff, excellent food, fast delivery. 5..."
Frank Smith
"Good food and a pleasant atmosphere
One word..."
Anthony Abbriano
"My favorite takeout and funnier than late night..."
Pat Nangano Sonnenshen
"Great great great..."
Douglas Ferrera
"If 10 stars were available DiLeo's Pizza would get it. Live in VA but had to travel to NY for a funeral. We wanted to eat pizza in " New York" and..."
Jaron Young
"Phenomenal pizza. Had the best experience & LOVE the garlic knots, buffalo wings, vodka sauce with ANYTHING & caesar pie. 11/10 highly..."
Jessica T
"I was in town for a funeral, it was late, DiLeo's was across the street. Didn't think too much of it, but we found one of the gold standards of..."
Nick
"Delivery was super quick and friendly. Ordered online which was very easy. The food was awesome. We got the baked ziti pizza and a chicken parm hero..."
"We had such a wonderful time celebrating our Engagement tonight among family and close friends. The service, staff, and the owner herself were all..."
Katey Olds
"A wonderful experience everytime you go there. A sophisticated restaurant with delicious food and the best view at the end of Staten Island. Enjoy..."
Mike Friedman
"Phenomenal!! This place is absolutely gorgeous from the chandeliers hanging in the air outside which look as if they are floating with a swing( that..."
Danielle Sydney
"Wonderful food
Wonderful atmosphere
Wonderful staff
We enjoyed our 10 year anniversary and twenty years together ❤️
Perfect..."
Sonny Cancel
"Was there for our Office Christmas lunch. Service was amazing, staff kind, polite & attentive. The food was beyond amazing. There were 10 of us &..."
Christine Grillo
"Hello, my wife and I stopped in on a whim from Pennsylvania last evening and what a wonderful evening we had... from the wine to the appetizers our..."
David Clouse
"Beautiful room. Excellent service. Good delious! Definitely would..."
Fran Filomeno-Dore
"Thank you to Angelina and staff. I had a wonderful dinner. Great food & atmosphere. Menu & drinks are pricey but you get what you pay for. I had the..."
Darlene Colonna Loren
"There is no host as Grand as Angelina she brings the room to LIFE and her dishes satisfy the most discerning pallettes . Her legacy and team will do..."
Jennifer Patafio
"I have been here four times and the food and service were excellent every time. It's not inexpensive by Staten Island standards, but there is no..."
Rob Stumpf
"I hosted my husbands 50th birthday party at Angelinas last night it was amazing!! I recvd texts from our guests of what a wonderful party and how..."
Carol Musto Schiano
"Perfect evening! Great service; great food and great ambiance.
Highly recommend..."
Lester J. Figueroa
"It was great. Was there for a wedding. Food was good and great server. The grounds are very pretty for an outdoor..."
Carmen Velazquez
"Was amazing!!! The service staff... we had a great time a the..."
Valeria Desiqueira
"We had a lovely evening on the balcony. Our waiter totally catered to us and gave a great recommendation better than the options we asked about. Lots..."
There Is No Spoon
"Location Location. Read all reviews; Just had lunch today: The food was perfect, Edgar was the best, great wine selection. I will be back for..."
Piatto Di Mia Creazione Misto Marinato Di Mare Chef Alfredo Ziino
Piatto Di Mia Creazione Hamburgers Di Tonno E Ratatouille In Agrodolce Chef Alfredo Ziino
Veal Parmigiana Chop
Finocchio Salad
Mozzarella Di Bufala Alla Toscana
custard
Zio Toto Salad
Bolognese Pasta
Cappuccino
Burrata Caprese
Chicken parmigiana
Oysters Rockefeller
Fried calamari
Mushroom Risotto
Dessert Table
Sit down
Italian
Seating
Table Service
Wheelchair Accessible
Serves Alcohol
Parking Available
Reservations
Dinner
Lunch
Mid-range
"The food was amazing. I had a bacon wrapped jumbo shrimp for appetizer, and the filet mignon dinner. Service was on point and my wine glass was never..."
Javy Justice Lopez Jr.
"Awesome place and the atmosphere was great. I had the gluten free spaghetti with the carbonara sauce it was delicious and so was the red sangria. I..."
Jessica Clinton
"Very friendly staff! Had a party there food and service was excellent!! Highly recommend this..."
Gina Aguilar
"Great service great food only I wouldn't recommend sitting by the oven. I couldn't do that..."
Annamarie Cavagna Balzano
"Had a wonderful night with my family (including 3 little girls). Can not say enough good about the service but more importantly about the food...."
Graig Martin
"Zio Toto is a fabulous Italian restaurant. My husband, son, daughter-in-law, two toddler grandchildren and I went on a Tuesday evening, No special..."
Diane Zoccali
"Best of the best. ...
Great customer service. ...
Delicious food. ..
Good portion sizes.....
Large selection, something for everyone's taste.
Awesome..."
Connie Corda Callori
"I highly recommend Zio Toto. Excellent service and amazing..."
Diane Melita
"Excellent food, great staff, nice decor. Been there several times and will be there..."
Michael Major
"The food is absolutely amazing here. Great space and atmosphere with wonderful staff. Highly..."
Geri Anne D
"One of our favorites, the food is always amazing and the service is excellent,great time with great friends! more importantly, they never rush you..."
Andrea Saburro-Nasti
"First time there had a great time food was very good seafood was perfect I will go back oh yeah the pork chop was to dead..."
Anthony Merone
"Love it there great place food is awesome last night they had Steve maglio great night for my..."
Richard F Legotte
"A bit loud however that's the only negative. Food was delicious and company too. Each dish was unique and full of..."
Danielle Buckley
"Beautiful Italian restaurant for a date night or any special occasion. Went here on Thanksgiving eve for an intimate dinner close to closing and was..."
Bradley Popkin
"One of my favorite places to go. Great food and music. Fast service and polite..."
"I ordered a Lasagna Bolognese and it was great. One thing I would suggest is to put less sauce but that might just be my preference. Everything else..."
Ivan Shock
"The service is good and Theresa is experienced server. The mussels is..."
SD dunu
"We went there for dinner. The service was great and very attentive. My son has food allergies and they were accomadating and very helpful. The owner..."
Sal Puglia
"From day one, every experience I’ve had at Puglias has been top notch. It’s one of the best spots on the island. The food is spectacular, the..."
"Hands down, the best food on the Island!!!! The pizza and everything else on the menu is to die for. Even better than the food is hospitality of..."
Lou Tiboldo
"I have had several parties here! The food is outrageous! One of my favs is the fried calamari and my kids would say the margherita pizza! The staff..."
Carol Ann
"Tonight was our 1st time eating here and it most definitely will not be our last!! Best fried calamari we've ever had, as were the baked clams. The..."
Lisa Scarfone Notaroberta
"Every time we eat here the food is always great and the staff are friendly. I highly recommend this..."
Charlie Benway
"What a wonderful place. So warm and welcoming. The staff was awesome! The food was phenomenal. We were from out of town and wanted to have a..."
Margaret O'Carroll Feigle
"Loved it! The food was delicious and the owner and staff were so kind! All of the good came to us hot! And speaking of hot.. the hot roasted..."
Lillian Palumbo
"Traveled from Indiana, made it to Reggianos before it closed. Was worth the drive.Great food ,service and the nicest owner you will ever meet. That's..."
Andy Hammer
"Went here for the first time. It was fantastic. We started with a glass of red sangria. Then the 1/2 order of fried calamari. A tiny bit of salt made..."
Dawn Sweum Easparro
"My niece Jenn told me about this place. I live in Brooklyn and was visiting my friend in SI. Everything
Was delicious, gigantic portions and..."
Maria Mammano
"Hands down the best pizzeria restaurant on the Island, we live in Jersey and make it a point to eat here every Sunday. Calamari is pretty awesome..."
Jason Swartout
"This place is great! The food was delicious, the atmosphere is relaxed & staff was super friendly! Can't ask for more than..."
Mary Fargo
"Food is amazing and the portions are huge. Seeing Mike was the best part. He’s the best..."
Andrea Liota
"The best food clean place friendly did i say the best food..."
"We had my mother’s surprise party there in May, in the private room. Jimmy attended to us the entire night! He was excellent and the food was..."
Jules Yarcz
"Absolutely nothing negative to say about this place. Great experience that started out w.super friendly staff, a wonderful & accommodating waiter,..."
Lisa Pasciuto-Herrera
"I always rave about the food here especially da best chicken parmesan. But I always forget to mention how awesome Jennifer the hostess is. She is..."
George Gottfried
"I was there for the first time tonight. The service was great, the food is delish and the drinks on point... I already made this place the place to..."
Mami Lu
"Fantastic restaurant this is our go to lunch spot. They have $8 lunch specials that are generous portions and delicious. We have gone for dinner many..."
Melissa Guglielmino
"The best deal for delicious food. For $84.95 for two you get an appetizer each, main course ( including steak and seafood) , sides, a dessert each,..."
Maria Pandolfo Hart
"Everything you would ever want a New York neighborhood Italian restaurant to be ~ friendly smiles upon entering, top-notch waiters from appetizer to..."
Dorinda Selke
"Portobello cafe is a very nice restaurant to dine at. The food was delicious and the drinks are absolutely tasty! The service was excellent and I..."
Nancy Humbert
"Catered from Adam for my grandsons first birthday...cant say enough about how delicious the food was and the 2 gentlemen who did the set up were..."
Lisa Volpe
"Excellent as always. �� We enjoyed the rock shrimp tempura, house salad, fried calamari, veal sorrentino, and da best chicken..."
"I am leaving a review because this establishment does not deserve these false 1 star reviews. I have been here 3 times and each time has been great..."
Stephanie W
"This is my new favorite pizza place! There are so many options to choose from. Pizza, Pasta, Sandwichs you name it! There prices are great and the..."
Ashley Korbul
"I have had pizza all over New York City. This place is easily one of the best if not the best pizzas I have ever eaten. The baked ziti pizza was..."
kyle guerin
"Baked clams, fried calamari, mussels, pizza... There were 9 of us and we literally "pigged out". Everything was scrumptiously delicious and the..."
Rosanne Bianco
"The quality for those slices of pizza were delicious and thin slices just like the other pizzeria. I can’t wait to order again in that pizza..."
"I love this bakery. They always busy so don't go planning to be in a rush . Staff is exceptional , welcoming and patient. They have alot of options..."
Tommy Drezek
"Great options of Italian desserts and bread. You will find delicious cakes in various flavors. Bread and bakery products are definitely over the..."
Jeff Dur
"Delicious Italian bakery in Staten Island with a super efficient line and cheap prices yet high quality! The breads here were delicious and insanely..."
Yvonne meets Food
"My buddy at work put me onto the spot few months ago and I finally get to leave a review.
Biased to say anything about the staff because they always..."
Bernie Alvarez
"Stopped in early morning for the greatest Italian bread on Staten Island. Brick oven round, semolina, French and Italian. The bagels were phenomenal..."
Brett M
"It was my first time going there and they have many varieties of desserts. I tried mini tarts, mini cannoli and lobster tail. All of them were yummy..."
Zeynep Kurtar
"Oh my goodness they have the best breads and sandwiches. The seeded hero is to die for... Toasted with eggplant parmesan flowing over. Be sure to ask..."
"Everything was wonderful. The staff went above and beyond to accommodate us. The food was great with so many options. The Sunday brunch is totally..."
Stephanie Marie Hernandez
"This was my first time here and I thought it was fabulous ! Had Sunday brunch which was sumptuous! The wait staff was very attentive and the pianist..."
Patricia Christie
"The ambiance, friendliness of staff, and food was amazing! Can't wait to go..."
Carolyn Lorenzo
"Awesome place ! The waiters are superb and the owner of the Hotel even came to greet us. He and his wife chat with us and ask if were all served..."
Manny Roxas Jr.
"My sister and I usually go to Lorenzo's on Christmas Eve.....but we decided to try there for Easter Sunday.....it was absolutely delicious.....now..."
"Basil never ever disappoints! Pictured is a small arugula salad that comes with fresh tomatoes, red onion, slivered almonds and candied lemon peels!..."
Thomas P Smith NY, NJ REAL ESTATE
"Basil's is our new spot!! Great pizza and food! Finding good quality food at an affordable price is difficult to find on Staten Island. We are so..."
Latasha Collo
"I catered from them for my gender reveal party, I had about 30 people so I bought package 5 and there was plenty of food and even left over! Everyone..."
Lori Moon
"The Food has been great all three times I have ordered from there. The stuffed garlic know is huge! The hot basil sandwich is delicious and worth..."
Kevin
"Best pizza I've ever had - period (Rainy Day pie). Meatball parm panini - again, best I've ever had. And to top it off, the staff is amazing - go..."
"I can't believe they closed down; best pizzeria on the south shore! I heard the rent was raised ridiculously high so that's why they closed. I..."
Joseph Strum
"Been going there for 29 years since it was across the street .can't beat the staff especially Sophia and Bubba and Miguel. And Indio the cook. I will..."
Anthony Casale
"A little on the pricey side, but still the best pizza in the area,. Can be a little crowded, but the white pie makes it worth the..."
Laura Benetti
"The pizza here is the star of the show. I prefer while pies over slices. NY style pizza that can barely be..."
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes