I would still go for the Momo's across the street, but this is a solid choice for fancier pizza. I tried the Sherwood and the toppings, cheese, and crust were are all flavorful and different from what you would find anywhere else, but the oily pesto sauce overwhelmed everything in flavor and dripping oil. Prepare to eat with a fork and knife if you get the pesto sauce. Next time I would definitely try a red sauce. I am hesitant to commit to Northside Pies and have my heart broken because they are in a cursed location where multiple restaurants have gone out of business in the past few years.
Everything from this place is amazing: apps, salads, calzones, pizzas! And all with their unique, tasty spin - LOVE IT! I recommend the feta bruschetta, ANY of the specialty pizzas, and the bacon wrapped jalapeños! 😈
I finally got to this place and BOY was it worth it! For those who don't know, these guys are also the owners for Gaines Street Pies and Midtown Pies. I've long maintained that Midtown is better than Gaines...but now I have a wonderful problem because I'm wondering if Northside may be the best of the 3. Took My Daughter for her birthday cause she craves pizza like a lion craves gazelles and they were phenomenal! Service was on point. Restaurant was spotless. They turned it to the L.S.U game for me. Even gave me two free beers because the one I wanted wasn't available even though my waitress told me it was. The food was OUTSTANDING!!! I'll actually be going back the very next time I want pizza to check out their other options.
1355 Market St - Tallahassee
An error has occurred! Please try again in a few minutes