Sluurpy
Reset

3 restaurant menus in %{citta}, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)

Best Pumpkin Pie in New York City

3 restaurant menus in United States, (the ranking and the list of restaurants are based on the number of recommendations received from users in the last month, currently updated to December 2024)
Selected filters:
Ranking
Sort A-Z
near you
Filters
Two Little Red Hens
94/100 (2684 ratings)
Dessert
Bakeries
American
Cafe
Key Lime Pie
Cheesecakes
Chocolat Muffin
Carrot Cake
Cream Cheese Frosting
Key lime pie
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cheesecake
Yellow Cake Chocolate Cake
Cupcakes
4 Inch Marble Cake
Apple pie
Peanut Butter Mini and Chocolate Fudge
New York Cheesecake
Peanut Butter Fudge Swirl
Birthday cake
Bakery
Pumpkin Cheesecake
Pumpkin Pie
PB
Cherry Cheesecake
Mini Cupcakes
Cheesecake
Cakes
"Best cheesecake Iā€™ve ever eaten, so creamy on the inside, crust is thin and delicious on the outside, the cheese flavor is light, fresh, not..."
Luan Nguyen Minh (Luke)
"Love this shop! Got their cheesecake, Brooklyn blackout cupcake(mini) and a slice of pie. The cupcake was good, very moist and yummy, but too sweet..."
Tian G
"A New Yorker recommended me cheesecakes of here. I came here for only cheesecakes. But cupcakes kept calling me to get them so I got some. Cheesecake..."
S K
"Two little red hens is a bakery that reminds you what pastries should taste like. I had a simple coconut custard cupcake and mist say it makes me..."
Orlando Trinidad
"Best cupcakes in the world!! Came all the way from Canada and made sure we stopped here. Amazing service, moist, light, and finger licking good..."
Rawad Elias
"#1 spot in NYC for carrot cake. After trying countless places, this is the best carrot cake I've ever had. The cream cheese frosting is exquisite and..."
Mike Styckle
"One of the best bakeries in NYC in my opinion (at least for cupcakes because thatā€™s all Iā€™ve every bought here). Moist, not too sweet, really..."
Cal Vin
"This is such a quaint cute little bakery. They have all kinds of incredible cake and cupcake flavors you could imagine - PB, blackout chocolate,..."
Nicole Quilliam
"Ok so a cheeky cheese cake stop at one of the best bakeryā€™s there is... it didnā€™t disappoint. Cheesecake was epic and the pecan coffee crunch..."
Steven Collins
"Wonderful New York Cheesecake!!! Big love! Absolutely freshly soft cheesy layer & bottom with a pinch of caramel flavor. Yum! If any of my friends..."
Gala G
Little Pie Company
84/100 (2763 ratings)
Quick Bites
Dessert
Bakeries
American
Cafe
American
Breakfast
Oven-Fresh Muffins
PI Day Classic Apple Pie
Cheesecakes
Sugarless and Classic Apple Pie
Carrot Cake
Key lime pie
Piping-Hot Chicken Pot Pie
KeyLime Pie w Coffee
Cupcakes
Gingerbread
Apple pie
Arnold Palmer Drink
Pumpkin Pie
Lemon Meringue Pie
Cakes
Apple Pear Crumble Pie
Ny Cheesecake
Banana Bread
Blue Berry Apple Crumb Pie
Mississippi Mud Pie
Red velvet cake
Southern Pecan Pie
Banana Coconut Cream Pie
All the Pies & Cakes
Florida Key Lime Pie
Cheesecake
Applesauce Carrot Cake
Sit down
American
CafƩ
Gift Cards Available
Takeout
Seating
Wheelchair Accessible
Breakfast
Mid-range
"Nice folks! Excellent baked goods! It's like a little taste of home in the city. The mixed berry pie is great, and so is the Cherry pie. If I could..."
Stephen Smyly
"Fist real coffee in New York! Amazing cheesecake! And nice service. Will definitely return to this place..."
Polina Vilderman
"These folks are Ɯber good! I love their Apple Sour Cream and Walnut Pie! I also love the Cheddar crust apple, it's delish! So much to stay about..."
Michelle King
"Best pecan pie I ever had and their three-berry pie was the..."
Shari Bowen
"Their pie is INCREDIBLE and the coffee is good too . The staff is very nice. It's quite addictive and I'm not 100% sure there isn't cocaine in the..."
Ashanti J'aria
"My family loves the sour cream walnut apple pie. It has been a favorite for years and it tastes just as good as the first time that we had it. All..."
Lisa Ruocco Grillo
"The key lime pie was among the best desserts I have ever had in my entire..."
Kimberly Gatto
"This is the best place to get some sweets, pies, cupcakes and all that other goodness made with sugar. Sour cream and apple walnut pie is a..."
Jazmine Martinez
"Stumbled onto this little place on the way to the tour boat from Times Square. Delightful! Friendly service and perfect tiny..."
Susan Fetcho
"Love this place!! The selection changes to incorporate seasonal offerings but maintains the standards. Check this place out; you'll be glad you..."
Sean James
"Sudden hankering for old-fashioned chicken pot pie and the need for not wandering to far from our hotel brought us to Little Pie Company. But donā€™t..."
Jane Tweety
"Great Pie!. Loved their famous sour cream, apple and walnut pie! Absolutely delicious warmed up with a scoop of their vanilla ice cream. We came here..."
Nicola
"Good but not great!. I had the key lime & my daughter had the cherry pie. Both were good but not fantastic. $8 for a small individual size pie is way..."
Rhonda
"Granted, I've learned that I'm not a fan of key lime pie - too tart for my taste - but their pie crust is amazing, and the sour cream apple is not..."
SukMon
"The Little Pie Company was on my radar for a while and I confess that I lured Jodi to that place, making sure we would pass in front of it when going..."
I Just Want To Eat
"Nice neighborhood pie shop. It features a variety of pie, bread loafs, and drinks. The sour creme walnut apple pie is our favorite, but the sweet..."
C Neon
"Came to little pie co around 7PM and they had a small selection of pies 50% off! I was able to snag a delicious banana coconut cream pie. I also got..."
Nicole Louie
"We stopped by for an afternoon treat and tried the sour cream walnut apple pie! The sweet and crunchy topping compliments the thinly-sliced apples so..."
Ana Bassett
"Very authentic NUC cheesecake as well as other local specialities. The coffee and cappuccino are wow like Italy. Highly recommended for the quality..."
Rayhane Tabrizi
"Nice little eatery with amazing pie! Great service, try the Sour Cream Apple Walnut Pie with vanilla ice cream warmed up! The little pies are just..."
Courtney Fahn
"Love this place. People are nice. It's clean. Pies and cakes are delicious. These photos are Chicken pot pie and Banana Coconut Cream pie. I also..."
Lena P
"Very cute shop filled with pies, cakes, and cookies! Wasn't in the mood for pie so I got the zebra bar 10/10, lemon cookie 10/10, and carrot cake..."
Kirstin Leigh
"The Little Pie Company was the most beautiful cafe youā€™ll stumble on. The hospitality starts outside and works its way inside. The neighborhoodā€™s..."
Sade Eastmond
"NYC HIDDEN SECRET GEM! Make sure to put this place on your itinerary! Little Pie Company dishes out the most spectacular pies! Both mini personal..."
Victor Wilson
"Great bakery with large selection of baked pies and dessert. Very friendly staff and quick..."
John Vlahos
"The chicken pot pie was the best I have ever tasted. We had key lime pie for dessert, and it was perfect. You could taste the key lime with a hint of..."
Andy Dorman
"I'm not too much of a pie fan. But I must admit that this is the best pie that I've tried. The apple and nuts pie is the best. Highly..."
Felipe Ramos Garcia
"I inquired about pies for Thanksgiving. My friend ordered three different ones. They were all delicious. Took home berry one. Ate last piece..."
Lesli Klein
"Had the bourbon pecan pie and Mississippi mud pie. Can't go wrong with either one though I'm partial to the pecan. Highly recommend this..."
Butch Hallmark
Grandma's Pizza
80/100 (399 ratings)
Restaurants
Pizza
Dinner
Lunch
Pizza Pie
Salad bar
cheese pizza
Pumpkin Pie
Pizza Fries
N Cheese
Tuna Wrap
Ice coffee
Pizza
Seating
Table Service
Accepts Credit Cards
Delivery
Takeout
Dinner
Lunch